and let him not think that he shall receive anything of the Lord. For if with the heart he had
believed unto righteousness, and with the mouth had confessed the truth unto salvation,
he would have asked forgiveness for his writings, at the same time correcting them. But this
he has by no means done, for he remained like Æthiops with his skin unchanged. In inter-
preting the verse ‘I said to the Lord, Thou art my Lord,’ he has strayed far away from the
70
true sense, for this is what he says: ‘By the laws of nature every son’s father must be his lord;
wherefore God who begat him must be at the same time God, Lord, and Father of the only-
begotten Son of God.’ So also in his epistle to the holy Alexander, the teacher of the great
Athanasius, which begins thus: ‘With what anxiety and with what care have I set about
writing this letter,’ in most open blasphemy he speaks as follows concerning Arius and his
followers: ‘Thy letter accuses them of saying that the Son was made out of nothing, like all
men. But they have produced their own epistle which they wrote to thee, in which they give
an account of their faith, and expressly confess that “the God of the law and of the prophets
and of the New Testament, before eternal ages begat an only-begotten Son, through whom
also he made the ages and the universe; and that he begat him not in appearance, but in
truth, and subjected him to his own will, unchangeable and immutable, a perfect creature
of God, but not as one of the creatures.” If, therefore, the letter received from them tells the
truth, they wholly contradict thee, in that they confess that the Son of God who existed before
eternal ages, and through whom he made the world, is unchangeable and a perfect creature
of God, but not as one of the creatures. But thy epistle accuses them of saying that the Son
was made as one of the creatures. They do not say this, but clearly declare that he was not
as one of the creatures. See if cause is not immediately given them again to attack and to
misrepresent whatever they please. Again thou findest fault with them for saying that He
who is begat him who was not. I wonder if any one is able to say anything else than that.
For if He who is is one, it is plain that everything has been made by Him and after Him. But
if He who is is not the only one, but there was also a Son existing, how did He who is beget
him who was existing? For thus those existing would be two.’ These things then Eusebius
wrote to the illustrious Alexander; but there are also other epistles of his directed to the
same holy man, in which are found various blasphemies in defense of the followers of Arius.
So also, in writing to the bishop Euphration, he blasphemes most openly; his letter begins
thus: ‘I return to my Lord all thanks’; and farther on: ‘For we do not say that the Son was
with the Father, but that the Father was before the Son. But the Son of God himself, knowing
well that he was greater than all, and knowing that he was other than the Father, and less
than and subject to Him, very piously teaches this to us also when he says, “The Father who
sent me is greater than I.”’ And farther on: ‘Since the Son also is himself God, but not true
God.’ So then from these writings of his he shows that he holds to the doctrines of Arius
and his followers. And with this rebellious heresy of theirs the inventors of that Arian
madness hold to one nature in hypostatic union, and affirm that our Lord took upon himself
105
Testimonies of the Ancients Against Eusebius.