§3.
Eusebius as a Historian. The Merits and Defects of his
History
.
The whole Christian world has
reason to be thankful that there lived at the opening of the fourth
century a man who, with his life spanning one of the greatest epochs
that has occurred in the history of the Church, with an intimate
experimental knowledge of the old and of the new condition of things,
was able to conceive so grand a plan and possessed the means and the
ability to carry it out. Had he written nothing else, Eusebius’
Church History
would have made him immortal; for if immortality
be a fitting reward for large and lasting services, few possess a
clearer title to it than the author of that work. The value of the
History
to us lies not in its literary merit, but in the wealth
of the materials which it furnishes for a knowledge of the early
Church. How many prominent figures of the first three centuries are
known to us only from the pages of Eusebius; how many fragments,
priceless on account of the light which they shed upon movements of
momentous and far-reaching consequence, have been preserved by him
alone; how often a hint dropped, a casual statement made in passing, or
the mention of some apparently trifling event, gives the clue which
enables us to unravel some perplexing labyrinth, or to fit into one
whole various disconnected and apparently unrelated elements, and thus
to trace the steps in the development of some important historical
movement whose rise and whose bearing must
otherwise remain an unsolved
riddle. The work reveals no sympathy with Ebionism, Gnosticism, and
Montanism, and little appreciation of their real nature, and yet our
knowledge of their true significance and of their place in history is
due in considerable part to facts respecting the movements or their
leaders which Eusebius alone has recorded or preserved. To understand
the development of the Logos Christology we must comprehend the
significance of the teaching of Paul of Samosata, and how inadequate
would our knowledge of the nature of that teaching be without the
epistle quoted in Book VII. chap. 30. How momentous were the
consequences of the paschal controversies, and how dark would they be
were it not for the light shed upon them by our author. How important,
in spite of their tantalizing brevity and obscurity, the fragments of
Papias’ writings; how interesting the extracts from the memoirs
of Hegesippus; how suggestive the meager notices from Dionysius of
Corinth, from Victor of Rome, from Melito, from Caius; how instructive
the long and numerous quotations from the epistles of Dionysius of
Alexandria! He may often fail to appreciate the significance of the
events which he records, he may in many cases draw unwarranted
conclusions from the premises which he states, he may sometimes
misinterpret his documents and misunderstand men and movements, but in
the majority of cases he presents us with the material upon which to
form our own judgments, and if we differ with him we must at the same
time thank him for the data which have enabled us independently to
reach other results.
But the value of Eusebius’
Church History
does not lie solely in the fact that it contains
so many original sources which would be otherwise unknown to us. It is
not merely a thesaurus, it is a history in the truest sense, and it
possesses an intrinsic value of its own, independent of its quotations
from other works. Eusebius possessed extensive sources of knowledge no
longer accessible to us. His
History
contains the results of his
extended perusal of many works which are now irrecoverably lost, of his
wide acquaintance with the current traditions of his day, of his
familiar intercourse with many of the chief men of the age. If we cut
out all the documents which he quotes, there still remains an extensive
history whose loss would leave an irreparable blank in our knowledge of
the early Church. How invaluable, for instance, to mention but one
matter, are the researches of our author in regard to the circulation
of the books of the New Testament: his testimony to the condition of
the canon in his own time, and to the more or less widespread use of
particular writings by the Fathers of preceding centuries. Great as is
the value of the sources which Eusebius quotes, those that he does not
give are still more extensive, and it is the knowledge gained from them
which he has transmitted to us.
The worth of these portions of
his
History
must depend in the first place upon the extent and
reliability of his sources, and in the second place upon the use which
he made of them.
A glance at the list of his
authorities given in the index, reveals at once the immense range of
his materials. The number of books which he either quotes or refers to
as read is enormous. When to these are added the works employed by him
in the composition of his
Præp. Evang
., as well as the
great number which he must have perused, but does not mention, we are
amazed at the extent of his reading. He must have been a voracious
reader from his earliest years, and he must have possessed
extraordinary acquisitive powers. It is safe to say that there was
among the Fathers, with the possible exception of Origen, no more
learned man than he. He thus possessed one of the primary
qualifications of the historian. And yet even in this respect he had
his limitations. He seems to have taken no pains to acquaint himself
with the works of heretics, but to have been content to take his
knowledge of them at second hand. And still further, he was sadly
ignorant of Latin literature and of the Latin Church in general (see
below, p. 106); in fact, we must not expect to glean from his
History
a very thorough or extended knowledge of western
Christendom.
But his sources were not
confined to literary productions. He had a wide acquaintance with the
world, and he was enabled to pick up much from his intercourse with
other men and with different peoples that he could not have found upon
the shelves of the Cæsarean or of any other
library. Moreover, he had
access to the archives of state and gathered from them much information
quite inaccessible to most men. He was thus peculiarly fitted, both by
nature and by circumstances, for the task of acquiring material, the
first task of the genuine historian.
But the value of his work must
depend in the second place upon the wisdom and honesty with which he
used his sources, and upon the faithfulness and accuracy with which he
reproduced the results thus reached. We are therefore led to enquire as
to his qualifications for this part of his work.
We notice, in the first place,
that he was very diligent in the use of his sources. Nothing seems to
have escaped him that might in any way bear upon the particular subject
in hand. When he informs us that a certain author nowhere mentions a
book or an event, he is, so far as I am aware, never mistaken. When we
realize how many works he read entirely through for the sake of
securing a single historical notice, and how many more he must have
read without finding anything to his purpose, we are impressed with his
untiring diligence. To-day, with our convenient indexes, and with the
references at hand which have been made by many other men who have
studied the writings of the ancients, we hardly comprehend what an
amount of labor the production of a
History
like Eusebius’
must have cost him, a pioneer in that kind of work.
In the second place, we are
compelled to admire the sagacity which our author displays in the
selection of his materials. He possessed the true instinct of the
historian, which enabled him to pick out the salient points and to
present to the reader just that information which he most desires. We
shall be surprised upon examining his work to see how little it
contains which it is not of the utmost importance for the student of
early Church history to know, and how shrewdly the author has
anticipated most of the questions which such a student must ask. He saw
what it was in the history of the first three centuries of the Church
which posterity would most desire to know, and he told them. His wisdom
in this respect is all the more remarkable when compared with the
unwisdom of most of his successors, who filled their works with legends
of saints and martyrs, which, however fascinating they may have been to
the readers of that age, possess little either of interest or of value
for us. When he wishes to give us a glimpse of the persecutions of
those early days, his historical and literary instinct leads him to
dwell especially upon two thoroughly representative cases,—the
martyrdom of Polycarp and the sufferings of the churches of Lyons and
Vienne,—and to preserve for posterity two of the noblest
specimens of martyrological literature which the ancient Church
produced. It is true that he sometimes erred in his judgment as to the
wants of future readers; we could wish that he had been somewhat fuller
and clearer on many points, and that he had not so entirely neglected
some others; but on the whole I am of the opinion that few historical
works, ancient or modern, have in the same compass better fulfilled
their mission in this respect.
In the third place, we can
hardly fail to be impressed by the wisdom with which Eusebius
discriminated between reliable and unreliable sources. Judged by the
modern standard he may fall short as a literary critic, but judged by
the standard of antiquity he must be given a very high rank. Few indeed
are the historians of ancient times, secular or ecclesiastical, who can
compare with Eusebius for sound judgment in this matter. The general
freedom of his work from the fables and prodigies, and other improbable
or impossible tales which disfigure the pages of the great majority
even of the soberest of ancient historians, is one of its most marked
features. He shows himself uncommonly particular in demanding good
evidence for the circumstances which he records, and uncommonly shrewd
in detecting spurious and unreliable sources. When we remember the
great number of pseudonymous works which were current in his day we are
compelled to admire his care and his discrimination. Not that he always
succeeded in detecting the false. More than once he was sadly at fault
(as for instance in regard to the Abgarus correspondence and
Josephus’ testimony to Christ), and has in consequence been
severely denounced or held up to unsparing ridicule by many modern
writers. But the wonder certainly is not that he erred as often as he
did, but that he did not err oftener; not that he was sometimes
careless in
regard to the reliability of his sources, but that he was ever as
careful as, in the majority of cases, he has proved himself to be. In
fact, comparing him with other writers of antiquity, we cannot commend
too highly the care and the skill with which he usually discriminated
between the true and the false.
In the fourth place, he deserves
all praise for his constant sincerity and unfailing honesty. I believe
that emphasis should be laid upon this point for the reason that
Eusebius’ reputation has often suffered sadly in consequence of
the unjust imputations, and the violent accusations, which it was for a
long time the fashion to make against him, and which lead many still to
treat his statements with distrust, and his character with contempt.
Gibbon’s estimate of his honesty is well known and has been
unquestioningly accepted in many quarters, but it is none the less
unjust, and in its implications quite untrue to the facts. Eusebius
does dwell with greater fullness upon the virtues than upon the vices
of the early Church, upon its glory than upon its shame, and he tells
us directly that it is his intention so to do (
H. E
. VIII. 2),
but he never undertakes to conceal the sins of the Christians, and the
chapter immediately preceding contains a denunciation of their
corruptness and wickedness uttered in no faint terms. In fact, in the
face of these and other candid passages in his work, it is the sheerest
injustice to charge him with dishonesty and unfairness because he
prefers, as almost any Christian historian must, to dwell with greater
fullness of detail upon the bright than upon the dark side of the
picture. Scientific, Eusebius’ method, in this respect, doubtless
is not; but dishonest, no one has a right to call it. The most severe
attack which has been made upon Eusebius in recent years is found in an
article by Jachmann (see below, p. 55). The evident animus which runs
through his entire paper is very unpleasant; the conclusions which he
draws are, to say the least, strained. I cannot enter here into a
consideration of his positions; most of them are examined below in the
notes upon the various passages which he discusses. The whole article,
like most similar attacks, proceeds upon the supposition that our
author is guilty, and then undertakes simply to find evidence of that
which is already presupposed. I submit that few writers could endure
such an ordeal. If Eusebius is tried according to the principles of
common justice, and of sound literary criticism, I am convinced, after
long and careful study, that his sincerity and honesty of purpose
cannot be impeached. The particular instances which have been urged as
proving his dishonesty will be discussed below in the notes upon the
respective passages, and to those the reader is referred (compare
especially pp. 88, 98, 100, 111, 112, 114, 127, 194).
Eusebius’ critics are wont
to condemn him severely for what they are pleased to call the
dishonesty displayed by him in his
Vita Constantini
. Such
critics forget, apparently, that that work pretends to be, not a
history, but a panegyric. Judging it as such, I am unable to find
anything in it which leads me to entertain for a moment a suspicion of
the author’s honesty. It is true that Eusebius emphasizes the
Emperor’s good qualities, and fails to mention the darker spots
in his character; but so far as I am aware he misstates no facts, and
does only what those who eulogize deceased friends are accustomed to do
the world over. For a discussion of this matter the reader is referred
to the prolegomena of Dr. Richardson, pp. 467 sq. of this volume. I am
pleased to learn from him that his study of the
Vita
has shown
him nothing which justifies the charge of dishonesty brought against
Eusebius.
One of the most decisive marks
of veracity upon the part of our author is the frankness with which he
confesses his lack of knowledge upon any subject (cf. IV. 5), and the
care with which he distinguishes between the different kinds of
evidence upon which he bases his statements. How frequently the
phrases
λόγος
žχει
,
φασί
,
λέγεται
, &c., occur in connection with accounts which a less
scrupulous historian would not hesitate to record as undoubted fact.
How particular he is to mention his sources for any unusual or
startling event. If the authorities seem to him quite inadequate, he
simply omits all reference to an occurrence which most of his
contemporaries and successors would have related with the greatest
gusto; if the testimony seems to him strong, he records the
circumstance and expressly mentions his authority, whether oral
tradition, the
testimony of eye-witnesses, or written accounts, and we are thus
furnished the material from which to form our own judgments.
He is often blamed by modern
writers for what they are pleased to call his excessive credulity.
Those who accuse him thus seem to forget that he lived in the fourth,
not in the nineteenth century. That he believed many things which we
now declare to be incredible is perfectly true, but that he believed
things that other Christians of his day pronounced incredible is not
true. Judged, in fact, according to the standard of his age—and
indeed of eleven succeeding centuries—he must be pronounced
remarkably free from the fault of over-credulity, in truth uncommonly
skeptical in his attitude toward the marvelous. Not that he denies the
occurrence of prodigies and wonders in his own and other ages, but that
he always demands the strongest testimony before he allows himself to
be convinced of their truth. Compare, e.g., the care with which he
gives his authorities for the anecdote in regard to the Thundering
Legion (V. 5), and his final suspension of judgment in the matter;
compare also the emphasis which he lays upon the personal testimony of
the Emperor in the matter of the appearance of the sign of the cross in
the sky (
Vita Const
. I. 28 sq.), a phenomenon which he himself
tells us that he would have believed upon no ordinary evidence. His
conduct in this matter is a sign rather of a skepticism uncommon in his
age than of an excessive and unusual credulity. Gibbon himself gives
our author due credit in this respect, when he speaks of his character
as “less tinctured with credulity, and more practiced in the arts
of courts, than that of almost any of his contemporaries”
(
Decline and Fall
, chap. XVI.).
On the other hand, Eusebius as
an historian had many very grave faults which it is not my wish in the
least to palliate or conceal. One of the most noticeable of these is
his complete lack of any conception of historiography as a fine art.
His work is interesting and instructive because of the facts which it
records, but that interest is seldom if ever enhanced by his mode of
presentation. There is little effective grouping, almost no sense of
perspective, utter ignorance of the art of suggesting by a single line
or phrase a finished picture of a man or of a movement. He was not, in
other words, a Thucydides or a Tacitus; but the world has seen not many
such as they.
A second and still more serious
fault is our author’s want of depth, if I may so express myself,
his failure to look beneath the surface and to grasp the real
significance of things, to trace the influence of opinions and events.
We feel this defect upon every page. We read the annals, but we are
conscious of no masterful mind behind them, digesting and comprehending
them into one organic and imposing whole. This radical weakness in our
author’s method is revealed perhaps most clearly in his
superficial and transcendental treatment of heretics and heresies, his
failure to appreciate their origin and their bearing upon the progress
of Christian thought. Of a development in theology, in fact, he knows
nothing, and hence his work lacks utterly that which we now look upon
as the most instructive part of Church history,—the history of
doctrine.
In the third place, severe
censure must be passed upon our author for his carelessness and
inaccuracy in matters of chronology. We should expect that one who had
produced the most extensive chronological work that had ever been given
to the world, would be thoroughly at home in that province, but in
truth his chronology is the most defective feature of his work. The
difficulty is chiefly due to his inexcusable carelessness, we might
almost say slovenliness, in the use of different and often
contradictory sources of information. Instead of applying himself to
the discrepancies, and endeavoring to reach the truth by carefully
weighing the respective merits of the sources, or by testing their
conclusions in so far as tests are possible, he adopts in many cases
the results of both, apparently quite unsuspicious of the confusion
consequent upon such a course. In fact, the critical spirit which
actuates him in dealing with many other matters seems to leave him
entirely when he is concerned with chronology; and instead of
proceeding with the care and circumspection of an historian, he accepts
what he finds with the unquestioning faith
of a child. There is no case
in which he can be convicted of disingenuousness, but at times his
obtuseness is almost beyond belief. An identity of names, or a
resemblance between events recorded by different authors, will often be
enough to lead him all unconsciously to himself into the most absurd
and contradictory conclusions. Instances of this may be seen in Book I.
chap. 5, and in II. 11. His confusion in regard to the various
Antonines (see especially the note on the preface to Book V.) is not at
all unusual among the writers of his day, and in view of the frequent
and perplexing use of the same names by the different emperors, might
be quite excusable in a less scholarly man than Eusebius, but in his
case it is evidence of unpardonable want of care. This serious defect
in our author’s method is not peculiar to him. Many historians,
critical almost to a fault in most matters, accept the received
chronology without question, and build upon it as if it were the surest
of foundations. Such a consideration does not excuse Eusebius; it
relieves him, however, of the stigma of peculiarity.
Finally, the character of the
History
is greatly impaired by our author’s desultory
method. This is a characteristic of his literary work in general, and
was referred to in the previous chapter. All his works are marred by
it, but few suffer more noticeably than the
History
. The author
does not confine himself as strictly as he should to the logical limits
of the subject which he is treating, but allows himself to be led away
from the main point by the suggestions that pour in upon him from all
sides. As Lightfoot remarks, “We have not unfrequently to pick
out from various parts of his work the notices bearing on one definite
and limited subject. He relates a fact, or quotes an authority bearing
upon it, in season or out of season, according as it is recalled to his
memory by some accidental connexion.” This unfortunate habit of
Eusebius’ is one into which men of wide learning are very apt to
fall. The richness of their acquisitions embarrasses them, and the
immense number of facts in their possession renders a comprehension of
them all into one logical whole very difficult; and yet unless the
facts be thus comprehended, unless they be thoroughly digested and
arranged, the result is confusion and obscurity. To exclude is as
necessary as to include, if one would write history with the highest
measure of success; to exclude rigidly at one time what it is just as
necessary to include at another. To men like Eusebius there is perhaps
nothing more difficult than this. Only a mind as intensive as it is
extensive, with a grasp as strong as its reach is wide, can accomplish
it, and few are the minds that are blessed with both qualities. Few are
the writers whose histories stand upon our shelves that fail not sadly
in the one or in the other; and in few perhaps does the failure seem
more marked than in our author.
And yet, though it is apparent
that the value of Eusebius’ work is greatly impaired by its
desultory method of treatment, I am confident that the defect is
commonly exaggerated. The paragraph which Lightfoot quotes from
Westcott on this subject leaves a false impression. Altogether too
often our author introduces irrelevant matters, and repeats himself
when repetition “mars the symmetry of his work”; and yet on
the whole he follows a fairly well ordered plan with fairly good
success. He endeavors to preserve a strictly chronological sequence in
his arrangement of the books, and he adheres for the most part to his
purpose. Though there may be disorder and confusion within the various
periods, for instance within the apostolic age, the age of Trajan, of
Hadrian, of the Antonines, &c., yet the periods themselves are kept
reasonably distinct from one another, and having finished his account
of one of them the author seldom returns to it. Even in his treatment
of the New Testament canon, which is especially desultory, he says most
of what he has to say about it in connection with the apostles
themselves, and before passing on to the second century. I would not
overlook the exceeding flagrancy of his desultoriness and
repetitiousness in his accounts of the writings of many of the Fathers,
especially of the two Clements, and yet I would emphasize the fact that
he certainly had an outline plan which he designed to follow, and for
which due credit should be given him. He compares favorably in this
respect with at least most of the writers of antiquity. Only with our
modern method of dividing history into periods, separated by natural
boundary lines, and of handling it
under clearly defined rubrics,
have we become able wholly to avoid the confused and illogical
treatment of Eusebius and of others like him.