The materials for an
authentic list are (1) the names given by Athanasius, Apol. c.
Ar. 50, previous to the lists of bishops from various
provinces who signed the letter of the council when in circulation.
These names, given with no specification of their sees, are 77 in
number. (2) The list of signatures to the letter of the council to
Julius, given by Hilary, Fragm. ii., 59 in number. The
signatures to the letters discovered by Maffei and printed in Migne,
Patr. Gr. xxvi. 1331, sqq. Of these, 26 sign (3) the
council’s letter to the Mareotic Churches, and 61, in part the
same, sign (4) the letter of Athanasius to the same (Letter 46
in this volume). These signatures comprise 30 names not given by
Hilary, while those in (1) add six which are absent from (2) and
(3) alike. This raises the total to 95. We add (5) Gratus of Carthage,
present according to the Greek text of the Canons, although he
afterward signed the letter in a local council of his own, like Maximin
of Treveri, Verissimus of Lyons, and Arius of Palestine, who are
therefore given by Athanasius in his second list (the former two being
omitted from the first): also Euphrates of Cologne, who was sent by
Constans to Antioch with the council’s decisions (Prolegg. ch.
ii. §6), and was therefore most likely present at the council
itself. We thus get 97 in all.