Chapter
IX.—Out of St. Luke’s Fifth Chapter are Found Proofs of
Christ’s Belonging to the Creator, E.g. In the Call of Fishermen
to the Apostolic Office, and in the Cleansing of the Leper. Christ
Compared with the Prophet Elisha.
Out of so many kinds of occupations, why indeed
had He such respect for that of fishermen, as to select from it for
apostles Simon and the sons of Zebedee (for it cannot seem to be the
mere fact itself for which the narrative was meant to be drawn
out
3711
), saying to Peter, when he trembled at the
very large draught of the fishes, “Fear not; from henceforth thou
shalt catch men?”
3712
By saying this, He
suggested to them the meaning of the fulfilled prophecy, that it was
even He who by Jeremiah had foretold, “Behold, I will send many
fishers; and they shall fish them,”
3713
that is, men. Then at last they left their boats, and followed Him,
understanding that it was He who had begun to accomplish what He had
declared. It is quite another case, when he affected to choose from the
college of shipmasters, intending one day to appoint the shipmaster
Marcion his apostle. We have indeed already laid it down, in opposition
to his
Antitheses
, that the position of Marcion derives no
advantage from the diversity which he supposes to exist between the Law
and the Gospel, inasmuch as even this was ordained by the Creator, and
indeed predicted in the promise of the new Law, and the new Word, and
the new Testament. Since, however, he quotes with especial
care,
3714
as a proof in his domain,
3715
a certain companion in misery
(
συνταλαίπωρον
),
and associate in hatred (
συμμισούμενον
), with himself, for the cure of leprosy,
3716
I
shall not be sorry to meet him, and before anything else to point out
to him the force of the law figuratively interpreted, which, in this
example of a leper (who was not to be touched, but was rather to be
removed from all intercourse with others), prohibited any communication
with a person who was defiled with sins, with whom the apostle also
forbids us even to eat food,
3717
forasmuch as the
taint of sins would be communicated as if contagious, wherever a man
should mix himself with the sinner. The Lord, therefore, wishing
that the law should be more profoundly understood as signifying
spiritual truths by carnal facts
3718
—and
thus
3719
not de
stroying, but rather building up, that
law
which He wanted to have more earnestly
acknowledged—touched the leper, by whom (even although as man He
might have been defiled) He could not be defiled as God, being of
course incorruptible. The prescription, therefore, could not be meant
for Him, that He was bound to observe the law and not touch the unclean
person, seeing that contact with the unclean would not cause defilement
to Him. I thus teach that this (immunity) is consistent in my Christ,
the rather when I show that it is not consistent in yours. Now, if it
was as an enemy
3720
of the law that He
touched the leper—disregarding the precept of the law by a
contempt of the defilement—how could he be defiled, when he
possessed not a body
3721
which could be
defiled? For a phantom is not susceptible of defilement. He therefore,
who could not be defiled, as being a phantom, will not have an immunity
from pollution by any divine power, but owing to his fantastic vacuity;
nor can he be regarded as having despised pollution, who had not in
fact any material capacity
3722
for it; nor, in
like manner, as having destroyed the law, who had escaped defilement
from the occasion of his phantom nature, not from any display of
virtue. If, however, the Creator’s prophet Elisha cleansed Naaman
the Syrian alone,
3723
to the exclusion
of
3724
so many lepers in Israel,
3725
this fact contributes nothing to the
distinction of Christ, as if he were in this way the better one for
cleansing this Israelite leper, although a stranger to him, whom his
own Lord had been unable to cleanse. The cleansing of the Syrian
rather
3726
was significant
throughout the nations of the world
3727
of their own
cleansing in Christ their light,
3728
steeped as
they were in the stains of the seven deadly sins:
3729
idolatry, blasphemy, murder, adultery,
fornication, false-witness, and fraud.
3730
Seven times, therefore, as if once for each,
3731
did he wash in Jordan; both in order that he might celebrate the
expiation of a perfect hebdomad;
3732
and because
the virtue and fulness of the one baptism was
thus
solemnly
imputed
3733
to Christ, alone,
who was one day to establish on earth not only a revelation, but also a
baptism, endued with compendious efficacy.
3734
Even Marcion finds here an antithesis:
3735
how that Elisha indeed required a material resource, applied water, and
that seven times; whereas Christ, by the employment of a word only, and
that but once for all, instantly effected
3736
the cure. And surely I might venture
3737
to
claim
3738
the Very Word also as of the Creator’s
substance. There is nothing of which He who was the primitive Author is
not also the more powerful one. Forsooth,
3739
it
is incredible that that power of the Creator should have, by a word,
produced a remedy for a single malady, which once by a word brought
into being so vast a fabric as the world! From what can the Christ of
the Creator be better discerned, than from the power of His word? But
Christ is on this account another (Christ), because He acted
differently from Elisha—because,
in fact
, the master is
more powerful than his servant! Why, Marcion, do you lay down the rule,
that things are done by servants just as they are by their very
masters? Are you not afraid that it will turn to your discredit, if you
deny that Christ belongs to the Creator, on the ground that He was
once
more powerful than a servant of the Creator—since, in
comparison with the weakness of Elisha, He is acknowledged to be the
greater, if indeed greater!
3740
For the cure is the
same, although there is a difference in the working of it. What has
your Christ performed more than my Elisha? Nay, what great thing
has the word of your Christ performed, when it has
simply
done
that which a river of the Creator effected? On the same principle
occurs all the rest. So far as renouncing all human glory went, He
forbade the man to publish abroad
the cure
; but so far as the
honour of the law was concerned, He requested that the usual course
should be followed: “Go, show thyself to the priest, and
present the offering which
Moses commanded.”
3741
For the figurative
signs of the law in its types He still would have observed, because of
their prophetic import.
3742
These types
signified that a man, once a sinner, but afterwards purified
3743
from the stains thereof by the word of God,
was bound to offer unto God in the temple a gift, even prayer and
thanksgiving in the church through Christ Jesus, who is the Catholic
Priest of the Father.
3744
Accordingly He
added: “that it may be for a testimony unto you”—one,
no doubt, whereby He would testify that He was not destroying the law,
but fulfilling it; whereby, too, He would testify that it was He
Himself who was foretold as about to undertake
3745
their sicknesses and infirmities. This very consistent and becoming
explanation of “the testimony,” that adulator of his own
Christ, Marcion seeks to exclude under the cover of mercy and
gentleness. For, being both good (such are his words), and knowing,
besides, that every man who had been freed from leprosy would be sure
to perform the solemnities of the law, therefore He gave this precept.
Well, what then? Has He continued in his goodness (that is to say, in
his permission of the law) or not? For if he has persevered in
his goodness, he will never become a destroyer of the law; nor will he
ever be accounted as belonging to another god, because there would not
exist that destruction of the law which would constitute his claim to
belong to the other god. If, however, he has not continued good, by a
subsequent destruction of the law, it is a false testimony which he has
since imposed upon them in his cure of the leper; because he has
forsaken his goodness, in destroying the law. If, therefore, he was
good whilst upholding the law,
3746
he has now become
evil as a destroyer of the law. However, by the support which he gave
to the law, he affirmed that the law was good. For no one permits
himself in the support of an evil thing. Therefore he is not only bad
if he has permitted obedience to a bad law; but even worse still, if he
has appeared
3747
as the destroyer of
a good law. So that if he commanded the offering of the gift because he
knew that every cured leper would be sure to bring one; he possibly
abstained from commanding what he knew would be spontaneously done. In
vain, therefore, was his coming down, as if with the intention of
destroying the law, when he makes concessions to the keepers of the
law. And yet,
3748
because he knew
their disposition,
3749
he ought the more
earnestly to have prevented their neglect of the law,
3750
since he had come for this purpose. Why then
did he not keep silent, that man might of his own simple will obey the
law? For then might he have seemed to some extent
3751
to have persisted in his patience. But he
adds also his own authority increased by the weight of this
“testimony.” Of what testimony, I ask,
3752
if not that of the assertion of the
law? Surely it matters not in what way he asserted the
law—whether as good, or as supererogatory,
3753
or as patient, or as
inconstant—provided, Marcion, I drive you from your
position.
3754
Observe,
3755
he commanded that the law should be
fulfilled. In whatever way he commanded it, in the same way might
he also have first uttered that sentiment:
3756
“I came not to destroy the law, but to fulfil it.”
3757
What business, therefore, had you to erase
out of the Gospel that which was quite consistent in it?
3758
For you have confessed that, in his
goodness, he did in act what you deny that he did in word.
3759
We have therefore good proof that He uttered
the word, in the fact that He did the deed; and that you have rather
expunged the Lord’s word, than that our (evangelists)
3760
have inserted it.
3711
Argumentum processurum
erat.
3712
See
Luke v. 1–11
.
3713
Jer. xvi. 16
.
3714
Attentius
argumentatur.
3715
Apud illum, i.e., the
Creator.
3716
Luke v. 12–14
.
3717
1 Cor. v. 11
.
3718
Per carnalia, by
material
things.
3719
Hoc nomine.
3720
Æmulus.
3721
Another allusion
to Marcion’s
Docetic
doctrine.
3722
Materiam.
3723
Unicum.
3724
Ex., literally,
“alone of.” So
Luke iv. 27
.
3725
Compare
2 Kings v. 9–14 with Luke iv.
27
.
3726
Facilius—rather
than of Israelites.
3727
Per Nationes.
[Bishop Andrewes thus classifies the “Sins of the Nations,”
as Tertullian’s idea seems to have suggested: (1)
Pride
,
Amorite; (2)
Envy
, Hittite; (3)
Wrath
, Perizzite; (4)
Gluttony
, Girgashite; (5)
Lechery
, Hivite; (6)
Covetousness
, Canaanite; (7)
Sloth
, Jebusite.]
3728
Compare, in
Simeon’s song,
Luke ii.
32
, the designation, “A
light to lighten the Gentiles.”
3729
[See Elucidation
I.]
3730
Such seems to be the
meaning of the obscure passage in the original, “Syro facilius
emundato significato per nationes emundationis in Christo lumine earum
quæ septem maculis, capitalium delictorum inhorrerent,
idoatria,” etc. We have treated
significato
as one member
of an ablative absolute clause, from
significatum
, a noun
occuring in Gloss. Lat. Gr. synonymous with
δήλωσις
. Rigault, in a
note on the passage, imputes the obscurity to Tertullian’s
arguing on the Marcionite hypothesis. “Marcion,” says he,
“held that the prophets, like Elisha, belonged to the Creator,
and Christ to the good God. To magnify Christ’s beneficence, he
prominently dwells on the alleged fact, that Christ, although a
stranger to the Creator’s world, yet vouchsafed to do good in it.
This vain conceit Tertullian refutes from the Marcionite hypothesis
itself. God the Creator, said they, had found Himself incapable of
cleansing this Israelite; but He had more easily cleansed the
Syrian. Christ, however, cleansed the Israelite, and so showed
himself the superior power. Tertullian denies both
positions.”
3731
Quasi per singulos
titulos.
3732
There was a
mystic completeness in the number
seven
.
3733
Dicabatur.
3734
Sicut sermonem
compendiatum, ita et lavacrum. In chap. i. of this book, the N.T. is
called the
compendiatum
. This illustrates the present
phrase.
3735
Et hoc opponit.
3736
Repræsentavit.
3737
Quasi non audeam.
3738
Vindicare in.
3739
Plane. An ironical
cavil from the Marcionite view.
3740
Si tamen major.
3741
Luke v. 14
.
3742
Utpote
prophetatæ.
3743
Emaculatum.
3744
[i.e., the Great High
Priest whose sacrifice is accepted of the Father, for the sins of the
whole world.]
3745
Suscepturus:
to carry
or
take away
.
3746
Legis indultor.
3747
Advenit.
3748
Atquin.
3749
Formam.
3750
Ab ea avertendos.
3751
Aliquatenus.
3752
Jam.
3753
Supervacuus.
3754
Gradu.
3755
Ecce.
3756
Sententiam.
3757
Matt. v. 17
.
3758
Quod salvum est.
3759
That is, you
retain the passage in St. Luke, which relates the
act
of
honouring the law; but you reject that in St. Matthew, which contains
Christ’s profession of honouring the law.
3760
Nostros: or, perhaps,
“our people,”—that is, the Catholics.