Heretics have frequently assigned reverence as the cause of their
opposition to the Church; and if even Arius affected it, the plea may
be expected in any other. ‘O stultos et impios metus,’ says
S. Hilary, ‘et irreligiosam de Deo sollicitudinem.’ de
Trin. iv. 6. It was still more commonly professed in regard to the
Catholic doctrine of the Incarnation. Cf. Acta Archelai [Routh.
Rell. v. 169]. August. contr. Secund. 9, contr.
Faust. xi. 3. As the Manichees denied our Lord a body, so the
Apollinarians denied Him a rational soul, still under pretence of
reverence because, as they said, the soul was necessarily sinful.
Leontius makes this their main argument, ὁ νοῦς
ἁμαρτητικός
ἐστι. de Sect. iv.
p. 507. vid. also Greg. Naz. Ep. 101. ad Cledon. p. 89;
Athan. in Apoll. i. 2. 14. Epiph. Ancor. 79. 80. Athan.,
&c., call the Apollinarian doctrine Manichæan in consequence.
vid. in Apoll. ii. 8. 9. &c. Again, the Eranistes in
Theodoret, who advocates a similar doctrine, will not call our Lord
man. Eranist. ii. p. 83. Eutyches, on the other hand,
would call our Lord man, but refused to admit His human
nature, and still with the same profession. Leon. Ep. 21.
1 fin. ‘Forbid it,’ he says at Constantinople, ‘that
I should say that the Christ was of two natures, or should discuss the
nature, φυσιολογεῖν, of my God.’ Concil. t. 2. p. 157 [Act.
prima conc. Chalc. t. iv. 1001 ed. Col.] A modern argument for
Universal Restitution takes a like form; ‘Do not we shrink
from the notion of another’s being sentenced to eternal
punishment; and are we more merciful than God?’ vid. Matt. xvi. 22,
23.