M.
de Mandajors, in his Histoire de l’Acad. des Inscript.
tom. 18, p. 226 (according to Gieseler’s Ch. Hist.,
Harper’s edition, I. p. 127), “thinks that the slave was
put to death as the betrayer of his master, according to an old law
renewed by Trajan; but that the occurrence had been misunderstood by
the Christians, and had given rise to the tradition, which is found in
Tertullian and in the Edictum ad Comm. Asiæ, that an
emperor at this period had decreed the punishment of death for
denouncing a Christian.” Such a law against the denunciation of
masters by slaves was passed under Nerva; but Gieseler remarks that, in
accordance with the principles of the laws upon this subject,
“either Apollonius only, or his slave only, could have been put
to death, but in no case both. Jerome does not say either that Severus
was the slave of Apollonius, or that he was executed; and since
Eusebius grounds this execution expressly on a supposititious law, it
may have belonged only to the Oriental tradition, which may have
adduced this instance in support of the alleged law.” It is
possible that Gieseler is right in this conclusion; but it is also
quite possible that Eusebius’ statement that the slave was
executed is correct. The ground of the execution was, of course, not,
as Eusebius thinks, the fact that he brought an accusation against a
Christian, but, as remarked by de Mandajors, the fact that, being a
slave, he betrayed his master. Had the informant been executed because
he brought an accusation against a Christian, the subsequent execution
of the latter would be inexplicable. But it is conceivable that the
prefect Perennius may have sentenced the informant to death, in
accordance with the old law mentioned by de Mandajors, and that then,
Apollonius being a senator, he may have requested him to appear before
that body, and make his defense to them, in order that he might pass
judgment upon him in accordance with the decision of the Senate. It is
quite conceivable that, the emperor being inclined to favor the
Christians, Perennius may not have cared to pass judgment against
Apollonius until he had learned the opinion of the Senate on the matter
(cf. what Neander has to say on the subject, in his Ch. Hist.).
As remarked by Valesius, the Senate was not a judicial court, and hence
could not itself sentence Apollonius; but it could, of course,
communicate to the prefect its opinion, and he could then pass judgment
accordingly. It is significant that the Greek reads ὡσὰν ἀπὸ
δόγματος
συγκλήτου, inserting the particle ὡσ€ν, “as if”;
i.e. “as if by decree of the Senate.”