INTRODUCTORY NOTICE. XV
bility of their argument to an unauthorised substitution. For
the me, in the above sentence they substitute " Joannem Cal-
vinum," and then interpret as if they stood, " nobody there
knew that John Calvin was the author." As already ex
plained, the two sentences have very different meanings ; and
it is only by means of the latter, which is altogether unau
thorised, that the argument in favour of an earlier first edition
is made to assume any semblance of plausibility.
But grant that the word " me" and " Joannem Calvinum,"
are in the sense here intended, convertible terms, and that
Calvin really meant to state that there was nothing on the
title-page of the First Edition which disclosed the fact that
he was the author, to what does it amount ? Certainly not
to a proof of what has already been shown to be scarcely
within the limits of possibility — the existence of an edition
of the Institutes antecedent to that of 1536. Almost any
supposition is more plausible than this ; and, therefore, before
adopting it, it would even require to be considered whether
there may not be some ground for the idea suggested by
Clement, that there were two sets of title-pages to the First
Edition — the one exhibiting the true name of the author,
and the other anonymous, or with a fictitious name, that
Calvin's own copy was of the latter description, and that
he naturally supposed it to be the same with all the rest.
This supposition becomes less extravagant than at first sight
it may appear to be, when it is considered that the double
titles conjectured for the First actually exist in the case of
the Second Edition, in 1539.
Holding it incontrovertibly established that the Edition
printed at Basle in 1536 is truly the first, it will now be proper
to furnish such information, with regard to it, as may serve
to give a tolerable idea of the original form of this celebrated