say that he framed for us a new exposition of faith? Why then do they calumniate the assent
of the most holy Bishops of Phœnicia, calling it a new setting forth of the Creed, whereas
233
they made it for a good and necessary end, to defend themselves and soothe those who
thought that they followed the innovations of Nestorius? For the holy Ecumenical Synod
gathered at Ephesus provided, of necessity, that no other exposition of faith besides that
which existed, which the most blessed fathers, speaking in the Holy Ghost, defined, should
be brought into the Churches of God. But they who at one time, I know not how, differed
from it, and were suspected of not being right-minded, following the Apostolic and Evan-
gelic doctrines, how should they free themselves from this ill-report? by silence? or rather
by self-defence, and by manifesting the power of the faith which was in them? The divine
disciple wrote, ‘be ready always to give an answer to every one who asketh you an account
of the hope which is in you.’ But he who willeth to do this, innovates in nothing, nor doth
he frame any new exposition of faith, but rather maketh plain to those who ask him, what
faith he hath concerning Christ.”268
2. The fathers of the Council of Chalcedon, by their practice, are authoritative exponents
of the Canon of Ephesus. For they renewed the prohibition of the Council of Ephesus to
“adduce any other faith,” but, in “the faith” which is not to be set aside, they included not
only the Creeds of Nice and Constantinople, but the definitions at Ephesus and Chalcedon
itself. The statements of the faith were expanded, because fresh contradictions of the faith
had emerged. After directing that both Creeds should be read, the Council says, “This wise
and saving Symbol of Divine grace would have sufficed to the full knowledge and confirm-
ation of the faith; for it teaches thoroughly the perfect truth of the Father, Son, and Holy
Ghost, and presents to those who receive it faithfully the Incarnation of the Lord.” Then,
having in detail shewn how both heresies were confuted by it, and having set forth the true
doctrine, they sum up.
“These things being framed by us with all accuracy and care on every side, the holy and
ecumenical Synod defines, that it shall be lawful for no one to produce or compose, or put
together, or hold, or teach others another faith, and those who venture, etc.” (as in the
Council of Ephesus).
The Council of Chalcedon enlarged greatly the terms although not the substance of the
faith contained in the Nicene Creed; and that, in view of the heresies, which had since arisen;
and yet renewed in terms the prohibition of the Canon of Ephesus and the penalties annexed
to its infringement. It shewed, then, in practice, that it did not hold the enlargement of the
things proposed as de fide to be prohibited, but only the producing of things contradictory
to the faith once delivered to the saints. Its prohibition, moreover, to “hold” another faith
shews the more that they meant only to prohibit any contradictory statement of faith. For
268 Cyril. Alex., Ep. xxxv., Ad Acac. Melit.
439
Excursus on the Words .