In a.d. 251 Novatus, a Presbyter of the Church of Carthage,
who with others had formed a party against S. Cyprian, their Bishop,
came to Rome, and excited Novatian to become leader in a similar schism
against Cornelius, the recently elected Bishop of the Apostolic
See. The plea urged on behalf of the schism was that Cornelius,
who was of one accord with Cyprian, had lapsed in the time of the
persecution under Decius, a.d. 250, and that
he had relaxed the discipline of the Church by admitting to Communion
on too easy terms those who had been guilty of a similar offence; and
that therefore he ought not to be recognized as a true Bishop of the
Church, but a faithful Pastor should be chosen in his place.
Consequently Novatian was elected by some who held these views, and was
consecrated by three Bishops. There seem to have been a good many
of his followers in Constantinople at this time. There had been
at one time a disposition among them to reunite themselves to the
Catholic Church, for they were orthodox in faith; but it had been
hindered by the malevolence of their party leaders; so that the schism
continued, and the Novatians must be added to the opponents with whom
S. Gregory had to deal.