227
of others. Before he proceeded further, John of Antioch requested that the Emperor’s edict
of convocation should be read, whereupon Candidian went on with his account of what
had taken place, and in answer to a fresh question of John’s declared that Nestorius had
been condemned unheard. John found this quite in keeping with the disposition of the
synod since, instead of receiving him and his companions in a friendly manner, they had
rushed upon them tumultuously (it was thus that he described what had happened). But
the holy Synod, which was now assembled, would decide what was proper with respect to
them. And this synod, of which John speaks in such grandiloquent terms, numbered only
forty-three members, including himself, while on the other side there were more than two
hundred.
John then proposed the question [as to] what was to be decided respecting Cyril and
his adherents; and several who were not particularly pronounced Nestorian bishops came
forward to relate how Cyril and Memnon of Ephesus had, from the beginning, maltreated
the Nestorians, had allowed them no church, and even on the festival of Pentecost had
permitted them to hold no service. Besides Memnon had sent his clerics into the residences
of the bishops, and had ordered them with threats to take part in his council. And in this
way he and Cyril had confused everything, so that their own heresies might not be examined.
Heresies, such as the Arian, the Apollinarian, and the Eunomian, were certainly contained
in the last letter of Cyril [to Nestorius, along with the anathematisms]. It was therefore
John’s duty to see to it that the heads of these heresies (Cyril and Memnon) should be suitably
punished for such grave offences, and that the bishops who had been misguided by them
should be subjected to ecclesiastical penalties.
To these impudent and false accusations John replied with hypocritical meekness “that
he had certainly wished that he should not be compelled to exclude from the Church any
one who had been received into the sacred priesthood, but diseased members must certainly
be cut off in order to save the whole body; and for this reason Cyril and Memnon deserved
to be deposed, because they had given occasion to disorders, and had acted in opposition
to the commands of the Emperors, and besides, were in the chapters mentioned [the ana-
thematisms] guilty of heresy. All who had been misled by them were to be excommunicated
until they confessed their error, anathematized the heretical propositions of Cyril, adhered
strictly to the creed of Nice, without any foreign addition, and joined the synod of John.”
The assembly approved of this proposal, and John then announced the sentence in the
following manner:—
“The holy Synod, assembled in Ephesus, by the grace of God and the command of the
pious Emperors, declares: We should indeed have wished to be able to hold a Synod in
peace, but because you held a separate assembly from a heretical, insolent, and obstinate
disposition, although we were already in the neighbourhood, and have filled both the city
and the holy Synod with confusion, in order to prevent the examination of your Apollinarian,
428
Excursus on the Conciliabulum of John of Antioch.