10. Moreover, when they speak of Pamphilus as one who
praised Origen, I am personally much obliged to them for accounting me
worthy to be calumniated with that martyr. For if, sirs, you tell me
that Origen’s books have been tampered with by his enemies to
bring them into discredit; why may not I in my turn allege that his
friends and followers have attributed to Pamphilus a volume composed by
themselves to vindicate their master from disrepute by the testimony of
a martyr? Lo and behold, you yourselves correct in Origen’s books passages which
(according to you) he never wrote: and yet you are surprised if a man
is said to have published a book which as a matter of fact he did not
publish. But while your statements can easily be brought to the test by
an appeal to Origen’s published works; as Pamphilus has published
nothing else, it is easier for calumny to fix a book upon him. For shew
me any other work of Pamphilus; you will nowhere find any, this is his
only one. How then can I know that it is by Pamphilus? You will tell
me, that the style and tone ought to inform me. Well, I shall never
believe that a man so learned has dedicated the first fruits of his
talent to defend doubtful and discredited positions. The very name of
an apology which the treatise bears implies a previous charge made; for
nothing is defended that is not first attacked. I will now bring
forward but a single argument, one, however, the force of which only
folly and effrontery can deny. The treatise attributed to Pamphilus
contains nearly the first thousand lines of Eusebius’s sixth book
in defence of Origen. If the text is
sound here Jerome is again misled by supposing that Eusebius and
Pamphilus had written separate books in defence of Origen. Yet in the
remaining parts of his work the writer brings forward passages by which
he seeks to prove that Origen was a Catholic. Now Eusebius and
Pamphilus were in such thorough harmony with each other that they
seemed to have but one soul between them, and one even went so far as
to adopt the other’s name. Eusebius calls
himself Eusebius Pamphili, that is, ‘the friend of
Pamphilus.’ How then
could they have disagreed so fundamentally on this point, Eusebius in
all his works proving Origen to be an Arian, and Pamphilus describing
him as a supporter of the Nicene council, which had not yet been held?
It is evident from this consideration that the book belongs not to
Pamphilus but to Didymus or somebody else, who having cut off the head
of Eusebius’s sixth book supplied the other members himself. But
I am willing to be generous and to allow that the book is written by
Pamphilus, only by Pamphilus not yet a martyr. For he must have written
the book before he underwent martyrdom. And why, you will say, was he
accounted worthy of martyrdom? Surely that he might efface his error by
a martyr’s death, and wash away his one fault by shedding his
blood. How many martyrs there have been all the world over who before
their deaths have been the slaves of sins! Are we then to palliate the
sins because those who committed them have afterwards become
martyrs?