What need is there to take time to recount all the other blasphemies that underlie his
doctrine, starting from this beginning? For by what we have quoted, one who considers the
inference to be drawn will understand that the father of falsehood, the maker of death, the
inventor of wickedness, being created in a nature intellectual and incorporeal, was not by
that nature hindered from becoming what he is by way of change. For the mutability of es-
sence, moved either way at will, involves a capacity of nature that follows the impulse of
determination, so as to become that to which its determination leads it. Accordingly they
will define the Lord as being capable even of contrary dispositions, drawing Him down as
it were to a rank equal with the angels, by the conception of creation617. But let them listen
to the great voice of Paul. Why is it that he says that He alone has been called Son? Because
He is not of the nature of angels, but of that which is more excellent. “For unto which of the
angels said He at any time, ‘Thou art My Son, This day have I begotten Thee’? and when
again He bringeth the first-begotten into the world He saith, ‘And let all the angels of God
157
worship Him.’ And of the angels He saith, ‘Who maketh His angels spirits, and His ministers
a flame of fire’: but of the Son He saith, ‘Thy throne, O God, is for ever and ever; a sceptre
of righteousness is the sceptre of Thy kingdom618,’” and all else that the prophecy recites
together with these words in declaring His Godhead. And he adds also from another Psalm
the appropriate words, “Thou, Lord, in the beginning hast laid the foundation of the earth,
and the heavens are the works of Thine hands,” and the rest, as far as “But Thou art the
same, and Thy years shall not fail619,” whereby he describes the immutability and eternity
of His nature. If, then, the Godhead of the Only-begotten is as far above the angelic nature
as a master is superior to his slaves, how do they make common either with the sensible
creation Him Who is Lord of the creation, or with the nature of the angels Him Who is
worshipped by them620, by detailing, concerning the manner of His existence, statements
which will properly apply to the individual things we contemplate in creation, even as we
already showed the account given by heresy, touching the Lord, to be closely and appropri-
ately applicable to the making of the earth?
617 The argument appears to be this:—The Anomœans assert, on the ground that He is created, that the Son’s
essence is τρεπτὸν, liable to change; where there is the possibility of change, the nature must have a capacity of
inclining one way or the other, according to the balance of will determining to which side the nature shall incline:
and that this is the condition of the angels may be seen from the instance of the fallen angels, whose nature was
inclined to evil by their προαίρεσις. It follows that to say the Son is τρεπτὸς implies that He is on a level with
the angelic nature, and might fall even as the angels fell.
618 Cf. Heb. i. 4, and foll. It is to be noted that Gregory connects πάλιν in v. 6, with εἰσαγάγῃ, not treating
it, as the A.V. does, as simply introducing another quotation. This appears from his later reference to the text.
619 Cf. Ps. cii. 25, 26.
620 Oehler’s punctuation here seems to be unsatisfactory.
300
He convicts Eunomius of having used of the Only-begotten terms applicable…