God, a revenger to execute wrath upon him that doeth evil.”2093 The whole question
therefore is, whether schism be not an evil work, or whether you have not caused schism,
so that your resistance of the powers that be is in a good cause and not in an evil work,
whereby you would bring judgment on yourselves. Wherefore with infinite wisdom the
Lord not merely said, “Blessed are they who are persecuted,” but added, “for righteousness’
sake.”2094 I desire therefore to know from you, in the light of what I have said above,
whether it be a work of righteousness to originate and perpetuate your state of separation
from the Church. I desire also to know whether it be not rather a work of unrighteousness
to condemn unheard the whole Christian world, either because it has not heard what you
have heard, or because no proof has been furnished to it of charges which were rashly be-
368
lieved, or without sufficient evidence advanced by you, and to propose on this ground to
baptize a second time the members of so many churches founded by the preaching and la-
bours either of the Lord Himself while He was on earth, or of His apostles; and all this on
the assumption that it is excusable for you either not to know the wickedness of your
African colleagues who are living beside you, and are using the same sacraments with you,
or even to tolerate their misdeeds when known, lest the party of Donatus should be divided,
but that it is inexcusable for them, though they reside in most remote regions, to be ignorant
of what you either know, or believe, or have heard, or imagine, concerning men in Africa.
How great is the perversity of those who cling to their own unrighteousness, and yet find
fault with the severity of the civil powers!
8. You answer, perhaps, that Christians ought not to persecute even the wicked. Be it
so; let us admit that they ought not: but is it lawful to lay this objection in the way of the
powers which are ordained for this very purpose? Shall we erase the apostle’s words? Or do
your Mss. not contain the words which I mentioned a little while ago? But you will say that
we ought not to communicate with such persons. What then? Did you withdraw, some time
ago, from communion with the deputy Flavianus, on the ground of his putting to death, in
his administration of the laws, those whom he found guilty? Again, you will say that the
Roman emperors are incited against you by us. Nay, rather blame yourselves for this, seeing
that, as was long ago foretold in the promise concerning Christ, “Yea, all kings shall fall
down before him,”2095 they are now members of the Church; and you have dared to wound
the Church by schism, and still presume to insist upon rebaptizing her members. Our
brethren indeed demand help from the powers which are ordained, not to persecute you,
but to protect themselves against the lawless acts of violence perpetrated by individuals of
your party, which you yourselves, who refrain from such things, bewail and deplore; just
2093 Rom. xiii. 2–4.
2094 Matt. v. 10.
2095 Ps. lxxii. 11.
819
To Emeritus