9. When they argue thus, they fail to perceive
the contradiction in which they involve themselves. For even though
they say that the Body is not from Mary, but is coessential with the
Word, yet none the less (the very point they dissemble, to avoid being
credited with their real opinion) this on their own premises can be
proved to involve a Tetrad. For as the Son, according to the Fathers,
is coessential with the Father, but is not the Father Himself, but is
called coessential, as Son with Father, so the Body, which they call
coessential with the Word, is not the Word Himself, but a distinct
entity. But if so, on their own shewing, their Triad will be a Tetrad The
argument rests on the principle that the Trinity is a trinity of
Persons, not of Essences: the opponents implicitly tax the Nicene
doctrine with the consequence that if truly man, Christ is a distinct
Personality from the Son.. For the true, really perfect and
indivisible Triad is not accessible to addition as is the Triad
imagined by these persons. And how do these remain Christians who
imagine another God in addition to the true one? For, once again, in
their other fallacy one can see how great is their folly. For if they
think because it is contained and stated in the Scriptures, that the
Body of the Saviour is human and derived from Mary, that a Tetrad is
substituted for a Triad, as though the Body created an addition, they
go very far wrong, so much so as to make the creature equal to the
Creator, and suppose that the Godhead can receive an addition. And they
have failed to perceive that the Word is become Flesh, not by reason of
an addition to the Godhead, but in order that the flesh may rise again.
Nor did the Word proceed from Mary that He might be bettered, but that
He might ransom the human race. How then can they think that the Body,
ransomed and quickened by the Word, made an addition in respect of
Godhead to the Word that had quickened it? For on the contrary, a great
addition has accrued to the human Body itself from the fellowship and
union of the Word with it. For
instead of mortal it is become immortal; and, though an animal ψυχικόν. body, it is become spiritual, and though
made from earth it entered the heavenly gates. The Triad, then,
although the Word took a body from Mary, is a Triad, being inaccessible
to addition or diminution; but it is always perfect, and in the Triad
one Godhead is recognised, and so in the Church one God is preached,
the Father of the Word.