This
passage has caused much trouble. Valesius remarks, “Africanus
wishes to refer the words ὡς ἐνομίζετο
(‘as was supposed’) not only to the
words ὑιὸς
᾽Ιωσήφ, but
also to the words τοῦ
῾Ηλὶ, which follow, which
although it is acute is nevertheless improper and foolish; for if Luke
indicates that legal generation or adoption by the words ὡς ἐνομίζετο, as Africanus claims, it would follow that Christ was the
son of Joseph by legal adoption in the same way that Joseph was the son
of Eli. And thus it would be said that Mary, after the death of Joseph,
married his brother, and that Christ was begotten by him, which is
impious and absurd. And besides, if these words, ὡς ἐνομίζετο, are extended to the words τοῦ ῾Ηλὶ, in the same way they can be extended to all which follow. For
there is no reason why they should be supplied in the second grade and
not in the others.”
But against Valesius,
Stroth says that Africanus seeks nothing in the words ὡς ἐνομίζετο, but in the fact that Luke says “he was the son
of,” while Matthew says “he begat.” Stroth’s
interpretation is followed by Closs, Heinichen, and others, but Routh
follows Valesius. Spitta discusses the matter carefully (p. 91 sq.),
agreeing with Valesius that Africanus lays the emphasis upon the
words ὡς ἐνομίζετο, but by an emendation (introducing a second ὡς ἐνομίζετο, and reading “who was the son, as was supposed, of
Joseph, the son of Jacob, who was himself also the son, as was
supposed,—for this he also adds,—of Eli, the son of
Melchi”) he applies the ὡς ἐνομίζετο
only to the first and second members, and takes it in
a more general sense to cover both cases, thus escaping Valesius’
conclusions expressed above. The conjecture is ingenious, but is
unwarranted and unnecessary. The words which occur in the next
sentence, “and the expression, ‘he begat’ he has
omitted,” show that Africanus, as Stroth contends, lays the
emphasis upon the difference of form in the two genealogies, “Son
of” and “he begat.” The best explanation seems to me
to be that Africanus supposes Luke to have implied the legal generation
in the words “the Son of,” used in distinction from the
definite expression “he begat,” and that the words
ὡς ἐνομίζετο, which “he also adds,” simply emphasize this
difference of expression by introducing a still greater ambiguity into
Luke’s mode of statement. He not only uses the words, the
“Son of,” which have a wide latitude, admitting any
kind of sonship, but “he also adds,” “as was
supposed,” showing, in Africanus’ opinion, still more
clearly that the list which follows is far from being a closely defined
table of descent by “natural generation.”