6. In the same way we also admitted
“begotten, not made;” since the Council alleged that
“made” was an appellative common to the other creatures
which came to be through the Son, to whom the Son had no likeness.
Wherefore, say they, He was not a work resembling the things which
through Him came to be Eusebius distinctly asserts, Dem. Ev. iv. 2, that our Lord
is a creature. “This offspring,” he says, “did He
first produce Himself from Himself as a foundation of those things
which should succeed, the perfect handy-work, δημιούργημα, of the Perfect, and the wise structure, ἀρχιτεκτόνημα, of the Wise,” &c. Accordingly his avowal in the
text is but the ordinary Arian evasion of “an offspring, not as
the offsprings.” E.g. “It is not without peril to say
recklessly that the Son is originate out of nothing ‘similarly to
the other things originate.’” Dem. Ev. v. 1. vid.
also Eccl. Theol. i. 9. iii. 2. And he considers our Lord the
only Son by a divine provision similar to that by which there is only
one sun in the firmament, as a centre of light and heat.
“Such an Only-begotten Son, the excellent artificer of His will
and operator, did the supreme God and Father of that operator Himself
first of all beget, through Him and in Him giving subsistence to the
operative words (ideas or causes) of things which were to be, and
casting in Him the seeds of the constitution and governance of the
universe;…Therefore the Father being One, it behoved the Son to
be one also; but should any one object that He constituted not more, it
is fitting for such a one to complain that He constituted not more
suns, and moons, and worlds, and ten thousand other things.”
Dem. Ev. iv. 5 fin. vid. also iv. 6., but was of an
essence which is too high for the level of any work; and which the
Divine oracles teach to have been generated from the Father Eusebius does not say that our Lord is “from the essence
of” the Father, but has “an essence from” the Father.
This is the Semi-arian doctrine, which, whether confessing the Son from
the essence of the Father or not, implied that His essence was not the
Father’s essence, but a second essence. The same doctrine is
found in the Semi-arians of Ancyra, though they seem to have confessed
“of the essence.” And this is one object of the
ὁμοούσιον, to hinder the confession “of the essence” from
implying a second essence, which was not obviated or was even
encouraged by the ὁμοιούσιον. The Council of Ancyra, quoting the text “As the
Father hath life in Himself so,” &c., says, “since the
life which is in the Father means essence, and the life of the
Only-begotten which is begotten from the Father means essence, the word
‘so’ implies a likeness of essence to essence.”
Hær. 73. 10 fin. Hence Eusebius does not scruple to speak
of “two essences,” and other writers of three essences,
contr. Marc. i. 4. p. 25. He calls our Lord “a second
essence.” Dem. Ev. vi. Præf. Præp. Ev.
vii. 12. p. 320, and the Holy Spirit a third essence, ibid. 15. p. 325.
This it was that made the Latins so suspicions of three hypostases,
because the Semi-arians, as well as they, understood ὑπόστασις to mean essence [but this is dubious]. Eusebius in like
manner [after Origen] calls our Lord “another God,”
“a second God.” Dem. Ev. v. 4. p. 226. v. fin.
“second Lord.” ibid. 3 init. 6. fin. “second
cause.” Dem. Ev. v. Præf. vid. also
ἕτερον
ἔχουσα τὸ
κατ᾽ οὐσίαν
ὑποκείμενον, Dem. Ev.
v. 1. p. 215. καθ᾽ ἑαυτὸν
οὐσιωμένος. ibid. iv. 3. And so ἕτερος παρὰ
τὸν πατέρα. Eccl. Theol. i. 60. p. 90. and ζωὴν
ἰδίαν ἔχων. ibid. and ζῶν καὶ
ὑφεστὼς καὶ
τοῦ πατρὸς
ὑπάρχων
ἔκτος. ibid. Hence
Athan. insists so much, as in de Decr., on our Lord not
being external to the Father. Once admit that He is in the Father, and
we may call the Father, the only God, for He is included. And so
again as to the Ingenerate, the term does not exclude the Son, for He
is generate in the Ingenerate., the mode of generation being inscrutable and
incalculable to every originated nature.