SECT. IX.
Several evasions of the arguments for the depravity of nature, from trial and events con-
sidered.
Evasion I. Dr. T. says, (p. 231, 232.) ”Adam’s nature, it is allowed, was very far from
being sinful; yet he sinned. And therefore, the common doctrine of Original Sin, is no more
necessary to account for the sin that has been or is in the world, than it is to account for
Adam’s sin. 16 Again (p. 52—54 S. &c.) “If we allow mankind to be as wicked as R. R. has
represented them to be; and suppose that there is not one upon earth that is truly righteous,
and without sin, and that some are very enormous sinners, yet it will not thence follow, that
they are naturally corrupt.—For, if sinful action infers a nature originally corrupt, then,
whereas Adam (according to them that hold the doctrine of Original Sin) committed the
most heinous and aggravated sin, that ever was committed in the world; for, according to
them, he had greater light than any other man in the world, to know his duty, and greater
power than any other man to fulfill it, and was under greater obligations than any other
man to obedience; he sinned, when he knew he was the representative of millions, and that
the happy or miserable state of all mankind, depended on his conduct; which never was,
nor can be, the case of any other man in the world:—then, I say, it will follow, that his nature
was originally corrupt, &c.—Thus their argument from the wickedness of mankind, to prove
a sinful and corrupt nature, must inevitably and irrecoverably fall to the ground.—Which
will appear more abundantly, if we take in the case of the angels, who in numbers sinned,
and kept not their first estate, though created with a nature superior to Adam’s.“ Again (p.
145. S.) “When it is inquired, how it comes to pass that our appetites and passions are now
so irregular and strong, as that not one person has resisted them, so as to keep himself pure
and innocent? If this be the case, if such as make the inquiry will tell the world, how it came
to pass that Adam’s appetites and passions were so irregular and strong, that he did not
resist them, so as to keep himself pure and innocent, when upon their principles he was far
more able to have resisted them; I also will tell them how it comes to pass, that his posterity
does not resist them. 17 Sin doth not alter its nature, by its being general; and therefore how
far soever it spreads, it must come upon all just as it came upon Adam.“
These things are delivered with much assurance. But is there any reason in such a way
of talking? One thing implied in it, and the main thing, if any at all to the purpose, is, that
because an effect being general, does not alter the nature of the effect, therefore nothing
more can be argued concerning the cause, from its happening constantly, and in the most
steady manner, than from its happening but once. But how contrary is this to reason! Suppose
a person, through the deceitful persuasions of a pretended friend, once takes a poisonous
16 Belsham.
17 See p. 81, note.
SECTION IX. Several evasions considered.
995
SECTION IX. Several evasions considered.