submit to baptism, &c. if their heart be not right with God. And such persons being admitted
to distinguishing ordinances, he calls an evil, in the present state of things unavoidable;
wishing for the happy medium, between prostituting divine ordinances by a foolish credulity,
and defrauding the children of the household of their bread, by a rigorous severity and mistaken
caution. He every where represents the Lord’s supper as the sacrament of nutrition, a reviving
and nourishing ordinance; but never that I can find, as a regenerating or converting one.
Upon the case of Judas, the Doctor observes, that if he had truly stated the order of the story,
then Judas certainly went out before the Eucharist was instituted: and indeed one cannot
reasonably suppose, Christ would have commanded him to drink of this cup as the blood
shed for him for the remission of sins, when he had just before been declaring in effect, that
his sins should never be forgiven.—By which observation, I think, Dr. Doddridge has quite
demolished one of the most plausible pleas in favour of the secret and conscious hypocrite’s
claim to the Lord’s supper.
In fine, even those who appear advocates for a latitude in admissions to the communion,
I observe, generally in the course of the argument offer such distinctions, or make such
concessions, as seem by fair consequence a giving up of the point, at least as stated in the
present question. For they usually distinguish between a right in foro Dei and in foro ecclesiæ;
accordingly treat these as two different questions, Who ought to come? and, Who ought to
be admitted? considering the latter as an ecclesiastical case, and here they assert a latitude;
but the former, as a case of conscience, of private reference only, and here they grant a limit-
ation. How large soever their principles, while taking the case in its ecclesiastical view, yet
I have met with very few divines, that taking it as a private case of conscience, have gone Mr.
Stoddard’s length, in asserting, that some unsanctified men have right before God to the Lord’s
supper, and may come with a good conscience, yea, ought to come, notwithstanding they
know themselves at the same time to be in a natural condition. This he declares in his Doctrine
of Instituted Churches, and confirms in his Sermon and Appeal. But then he has made some
concessions, which seem to be subversive of his opinion. For he expressly allows, that the
sacrament by institution supposes communicants to be visible saints; and this title of visible
saints he assigns to “such as have a visible union to Christ, such as are in the judgment of
rational charity believers, such as carry themselves so that there is reason to look upon them
to be saints.” Now, taking the case as a private case of conscience, (in which light only Mr.
Stoddard professes to have designed to consider it in his sermon, and not at all as an ecclesi-
astical case,) I think, this visibility of saintship immediately respects the proponant for the
Lord’s table, and must be referred to his own private judgment of himself. But then, how
can there be a visibility of saintship in the eve of the man’s own conscience, when at the same
time he knows himself to be in a natural condition? Or how can a man come to the Lord’s
table with a good conscience, as having right before God, while he cannot form so much as
a judgment of rational charity for himself; seeing he carries so, in the view of his own con-
1884
Appendix. Mr. Foxcroft's letter.