icating flattery.” Still it is not to be supposed that this was a peculiarly weak vanity or an
absorbing one. The testimony to his Modesty (V. C. 3. 10), though by Eusebius, is too cir-
cumstantial to be wholly unreal, and the testimony to his Humility in his “indignation at
excessive praise” (V. C. 4. 48), and the records of Eusebius that he “was not rendered arrogant
by these plaudits nor uplifted by the praises” (Euseb. V. C. 1. 39), and of the Chronicon
Paschale (p. 521) that “he was not at all puffed up by the acclamations,” evidently represent
428
a genuine thing. This mixed character is too frequently met with to be incomprehensible.
Real power, recognizing its own success, glad of the recognition of others, not at bottom
because of cold vanity, but from warm appreciation of human friendliness, became through
success in carrying out what seemed to him, and were, divine plans, fired with the thought
that he was the especial and necessary minister of God, that his thoughts and will were directly
touched by the Divine Will and thus that whatever he thought or willed was infallible. He
is not unlike some modern rulers. The spirit, though one of real vanity, or egotism at least,
has an element of nobleness in it, and in most of its manifestations commands respect along
with the smile. The accusation of Zosimus of Arrogance “when he had attained to the sole
authority,” and that he “gave himself up to the unrestrained exercise of his power,” must
be interpreted like those of other un-Christian witnesses, in the light of the fact that his ac-
tions worked relative hardships to the non-Christians, and that very justice to the Christians
would seem injustice to them, and if Constantine was more than just, his generosity was at
some one’s expense. His energy of execution and constant success, with his dominating idea
of a Divine mission, would naturally engender this faith in his own infallibility; for what is
arrogance but this vanity joined with power? His action toward schismatics—Donatists,
Arians, or orthodox troublers of his peace—was such as to suggest some degree of this vice.
Yet his success in keeping the followers of the old religion fairly mollified, and his generally
successful tact, showed that this was in no sense a dominating and unrelieved characteristic.
Two other weaknesses closely allied with these are also imputed to Constantine: Jealousy,
as illustrated by the statement that “wishing to minimize the deeds of his predecessors, he
took pains to tarnish their virtues by giving them jocose epithets” (Dion. Cont. 2 [Müller,
p. 199]; cf. Vict. Epit. p. 51), and Suspiciousness (Eutrop. 10. 7); for which latter, a man who
had survived as many plots as he had, might well be excused. Again and again and again he
trusted men, and they deceived him. His conduct with Maximian shows that at least in the
beginning, before he had had so much experience of untrustworthiness, he was remarkably
free from this. A much more serious charge is that of Faithlessness preferred by Zosimus,
who says (2. 28), “in violation of his oaths (for this was customary with him)” and twice re-
peats the charge. Eusebius, on the other hand, tells what great pains Constantine took not
to be the one to break peace with Licinius (V. C.). One is worth as little as the other. The
charge seems to rest mainly or wholly on his conduct towards Licinius, in beginning war
and in putting him to death. A small boy once held a smaller boy in a firm grip, but agreed
1070
Moral Characteristics.