11. We were present (we know the whole case) when the
bishop Epiphanius spoke against Origen in your church, and he was the
ostensible, you the real object of attack. You and your crew grinned
like dogs, drew in your nostrils, scratched your heads, nodded to one
another, and talked of the “silly old man.” Did you not, in
front of the Lord’s tomb, send your archdeacon to tell him to
cease discussing such matters? What bishop ever gave such a command to
one of his own presbyters in the presence of the people? When you were
going from the Church of the Resurrection to the Church of the Holy
Cross, and a crowd of all ages, and both sexes, was flowing to meet
him, presenting to him their little ones, kissing his feet, plucking
the fringes of his garments, and when he could not stir a step forward,
and could hardly stand against the waves of the surging crowd, were not
you so tortured by envy as to exclaim against “the vainglorious
old man”? And you were not ashamed to tell him to his face that
his stopping was of set purpose and design. Pray recall that day when
the people who had been called together were kept waiting until the
seventh hour by the mere hope of hearing Epiphanius, and the subject of
the harangue you then delivered. You spoke, forsooth, with indignant
rage against the Anthropomorphites, who, with rustic simplicity, think
that God has actually the members of which we read in Scripture; and
showed by your eyes, hands, and every gesture that you had the old man
in view, and wished him to be suspected of that most foolish heresy.
When through sheer fatigue, with dry month, head thrown back, and
quivering lips, to the satisfaction of the whole people, who had longed
for the end, you at last wound up, how did the crazy and “silly
old man” treat you? He rose to indicate that he would say a few
words, and after saluting the assembly with voice and hand proceeded
thus: “All that has been said by one who is my brother in the
episcopate, but my son in point of years, against the heresy of the
Anthropomorphites, has been well and faithfully spoken, and my voice,
too, condemns that heresy. But it is fair that, as we condemn this
heresy so we should also condemn the perverse doctrines of
Origen.” You cannot, I think, have forgotten what a burst of
laughter, what shouts of applause ensued. This is what you call in your
letter his speaking to the people anything he chose, no matter what it
might be. He, forsooth, was mad because he contradicted you in your own
kingdom. “Anything he chose, no matter what.” Either give
him praise, or blame. Why, here as well as elsewhere, do you move with
so uncertain a step? If what he said was good, why not openly proclaim
it? if evil, why not boldly censure it? And yet, let us note with what
wisdom, modesty, and humility this pillar of truth and faith, who dares
to say that so illustrious a man speaks to the people what he chooses,
alludes to himself. “One day I was speaking in his presence; and,
taking occasion from some words in the lesson for the day, I expressed,
in his hearing and in that of the whole Church, such views respecting
the faith and all the doctrines of the Church as by the grace of God I
unceasingly teach in the Church, and in my catechetical
lectures.”