of evil. But there is another reason for our present circumstances being what they are, and
for our being destitute of the primitive surroundings: and yet again the starting-point of
our answer to this argument against us is not beyond and outside the assent of our opponents.
For He who made man for the participation of His own peculiar good, and incorporated in
him the instincts for all that was excellent, in order that his desire might be carried forward
by a corresponding movement in each case to its like, would never have deprived him of
that most excellent and precious of all goods; I mean the gift implied in being his own
master, and having a free will. For if necessity in any way was the master of the life of man,
the “image” would have been falsified in that particular part, by being estranged owing to
this unlikeness to its archetype. How can that nature which is under a yoke and bondage to
any kind of necessity be called an image of a Master Being? Was it not, then, most right that
that which is in every detail made like the Divine should possess in its nature a self-ruling
and independent principle, such as to enable the participation of good to be the reward of
its virtue? Whence, then, comes it, you will ask, that he who had been distinguished
throughout with most excellent endowments exchanged these good things for the worse?
The reason of this also is plain. No growth of evil had its beginning in the Divine will. Vice
would have been blameless were it inscribed with the name of God as its maker and father.
But the evil is, in some way or other, engendered1955 from within, springing up in the will
at that moment when there is a retrocession of the soul from the beautiful1956. For as sight
is an activity of nature, and blindness a deprivation of that natural operation, such is the
kind of opposition between virtue and vice. It is, in fact, not possible to form any other notion
of the origin of vice than as the absence of virtue. For as when the light has been removed
478
the darkness supervenes, but as long as it is present there is no darkness, so, as long as the
good is present in the nature, vice is a thing that has no inherent existence; while the depar-
ture of the better state becomes the origin of its opposite. Since then, this is the peculiarity
of the possession of a free will, that it chooses as it likes the thing that pleases it, you will
find that it is not God Who is the author of the present evils, seeing that He has ordered
your nature so as to be its own master and free; but rather the recklessness that makes choice
of the worse in preference to the better.
1955 S. James i. 15: ἡ ἐπιθυμία τίκτει…ἁμαρτίαν
1956 τὸ καλὸν. The Greek word for moral perfection, according to one view of its derivation (καίειν), refers
to “brightness”; according to another (cf. κεκαδμενος), to “finish” or perfection.
890
Chapter V