(1.) This year is memorable for the
commencement of Gregory’s earnest protest, continued through his
subsequent life, against the title of Œcumenical, or Universal,
Bishop (or Patriarch) assumed by the Patriarch of Constantinople.
The title itself was not a new one. It appears to have been
occasionally given during the fifth century as a title of honour to
patriarchs generally, the first known instance being when Olympius
Episc. Evazensis gave it to Dioscorus at Concil. Ephes. ii.
(Giesler’s Eccles. Hist. 2nd Period, 1st Division, Ch.
iii., § 93, note 20; with ref. to Mansi, vi. 855).
Justinian also had styled the patriarch of Constantinople
“Œcumenical Patriarch” (Cod. i. 1, 7; Novell. iii.,
v., vi., vii., xvi., xiii.). The first known protest against it
from Rome was on its assumption, a.d.
587 That this was the
date may be inferred from Gregory, in Epistle XLIII. of this fifth
book, speaking of the synod having been held eight years ago., by John Jejunator at a synod at
Constantinople, when Gregory’s predecessor, Pelagius II., had
disallowed the acts of the synod in consequence, and had withdrawn his
apocrisiarius from communion with the patriarch (Epp. V. 18, 43;
IX. 68). Gregory himself also had, as appears from the epistles
above referred to, remonstrated through his representatives at
Constantinople with the patriarch on the subject, and had received a
letter from the emperor desiring him to let the matter rest (V.
19). But he was now provoked to resolute action by having
received a communication from the patriarch in reference to the case of
John the Presbyter, wherein the title of “Œcumenical
Patriarch” was repeatedly assumed (ib.). The
peculiar warmth of feeling and strength of language that mark his
lengthened correspondence on the subject, are accounted for not only by
the old jealousy felt at Rome (which has been noticed above) of any
claim of Constantinople, in mere virtue of being the imperial city, to
the prerogatives of an ancient Apostolic See, but also by the title
being viewed as not being one of honour only, but as meaning really
assumption of spiritual authority over the Church at large. Such
assumption could only rest on the fact of Constantinople having come to
be the imperial city: it had neither a shew of divine right, nor
Apostolic tradition, nor canonical authority to go on. Rome,
though for himself also Gregory earnestly disclaimed the title of
Universal Bishop, was at any rate an. ancient apostolic See, and viewed
at that time generally as representing the authority of the Prince of
the Apostles, to whom Christ himself had given the keys. But no
such ancient prestige or apostolical commission could possibly be
claimed for Constantinople: its ascendency over the whole Church
would simply mean imperialism, and imperial domination over the whole
Church would in fact have been likely to be its practical result:
and thus, in his determined protest, Gregory might well feel himself to
be contending for heavenly as against earthly jurisdiction, for Christ
as against the world, for God as against Cæsar.