apostle’s arguing, by Dr. T.‘s explanation of it, is turned into mere trifling, a vain and imper-
tinent use of words, without any real force or significance.
VI. The apostle here speaks of that great benefit which we have by Christ, as the antitype
of Adam, under the notion of the fruit of grace. I do not mean only that superabounding of
grace wherein the benefit we have by Christ goes beyond the damage sustained by Adam;
but that benefit, with regard to which Adam was the figure of him that was to come, and
which is as it were the counterpart of the suffering by Adam, and which repairs the loss we
have by him. This is here spoken of as the fruit of the free grace of God; (as appears by Rom.
v. 15-18, 20, 21.) which according to our author, is the restoring of mankind to that life
which they lost in Adam: and he himself supposes this restoration of life by Christ to be
what grace does for us, and calls it the free gift of God, and the grace and favour of the law-
giver.* 86 And speaking of this restoration, he breaks out in admiration of the unspeakable
riches of this grace.† 87
But it follows from his doctrine, that there is no grace at all in this benefit, and it is no
more than a mere act of justice, being only a removing of what mankind suffer, being inno-
cent. Death, as it commonly comes on mankind, and even on infants, (as has been observed,)
is an extreme, positive calamity; to bring which on the perfectly innocent, unremedied, and
without any thing to countervail it, we are sufficiently taught, is not consistent with the
righteousness of the judge of all the earth. What grace therefore, worthy of being so celebrated,
203
would there be in affording remedy and relief, after there had been brought on innocent
mankind that which is (as Dr. T. himself represents 88 ) the dreadful and universal destruction
of their nature; being a striking demonstration how infinitely hateful sin is to God! What
grace in delivering from such shocking ruin, them who did not deserve the least calamity!
Our author says, “We could not justly lose communion with God by Adam’s sin.” 89 If so,
then we could not justly lose our lives, and be annihilated, after a course of extreme pains
and agonies of body and mind, without any restoration; which would be an eternal loss of
communion with God, and all other good, besides the positive suffering. The apostle,
throughout this passage, represents the death which is the consequence of Adam’s transgres-
sion, as coming in a way of judgment and condemnation for sin; but deliverance and life
through Christ, as by grace, and the free gift of God. Whereas, on the contrary, by Dr. T.‘s
scheme, the death that comes by Adam, comes by grace, great grace; it being a great benefit,
ordered in fatherly love and kindness, and on the basis of a covenant of grace: but in the
86 * Page 39, 70, 148, 27. S. See also contents of this paragraph in Rom v. in his notes on the epistle, and his
notes on Rom. v. 15, 16, 17.
87 † Page 119. S.
88 Page 69.
89 Page 148.
1095
SECTION I. Remarks on Dr. Taylor's way of explaining this text.