Chapter
XLIX.
These are what are called presumptuous speculations in
our case alone; in the philosophers and poets they are regarded as
sublime speculations and illustrious discoveries. They are men of
wisdom, we are fools. They are worthy of all honour, we are folk to
have the finger pointed at; nay, besides that, we are even to have
punishments inflicted on us. But let things which are the defence of
virtue, if you will, have no foundation, and give them duly the name of
fancies, yet still they are necessary; let them be absurd if you will,
yet they are of use: they make all who believe them better men and
women, under the fear of never-ending punishment and the hope of
never-ending bliss. It is not, then, wise to brand as false, nor
to regard as absurd, things the truth of which it is expedient to
presume. On no ground is it right positively to condemn as bad
what beyond all doubt is profitable. Thus, in fact, you are guilty of
the very presumption of which you accuse us, in condemning what is
useful. It is equally out of the question to regard them as
nonsensical; at any rate, if they are false and foolish, they hurt
nobody. For they are just (in that case) like many other things on
which you inflict no penalties—foolish and fabulous things, I
mean, which, as quite innocuous, are never charged as crimes or
punished. But in a thing of the kind, if this be so indeed, we should
be adjudged to ridicule, not to swords, and flames, and crosses, and
wild beasts, in which iniquitous cruelty not only the blinded populace
exults and insults over us, but in which some of you too glory, not
scrupling to gain the popular favour by your injustice. As though all
you can do to us did not depend upon our pleasure. It is
assuredly a matter of my own inclination, being a Christian. Your
condemnation, then, will only reach me in that case, if I wish to be
condemned; but when all you can do to me, you can do only at my will,
all you can do is dependent on my will, and is not in your power. The
joy of the people in our trouble is therefore utterly reasonless.
For it is our joy they appropriate to themselves, since we would far
rather be condemned than apostatize from God; on the contrary, our
haters should be sorry rather than rejoice, as we have obtained the
very thing of our own choice.