4. What must I do then? deny that I am of Origen’s
opinion? They will not believe me. Swear that I am not? They will laugh
and say that I deal in lies. I will do the one thing which they dread.
I will bring forward their sacred rites and mysteries, and will expose
the cunning whereby they delude simple folk like myself. Perhaps,
although they refuse credence to my voice when I deny, they may believe
my pen when I accuse. Of one thing they are particularly apprehensive,
and that is that their writings may some day be taken as evidence
against their master. They are ready to make statements on oath and to
disclaim them afterwards with an oath as false as the first. When asked
for their signatures they use shifts and seek excuses. One says:
“I cannot condemn what no one else has condemned.” Another
says: “No decision was arrived at on the point by the
Fathers.” i.e. the
Bishops present at Nicæa. It is thus that
they appeal to the judgment of the world to put off the necessity of
assenting to a condemnation. Another says with yet more assurance:
“how am I to condemn men whom the council of Nicæa has left
untouched? For the council which condemned Arius would surely have
condemned Origen too, had it disapproved of his doctrines.” They
were bound in other words to cure all the diseases of the church at
once and with one remedy; and by parity of reasoning we must deny the
majesty of the Holy Ghost because nothing was said of his nature in
that council. But the question was of Arius, not of Origen; of the Son,
not of the Holy Ghost. The bishops at the council proclaimed their
adherence to a dogma which was at the time denied; they said nothing
about a difficulty which no one had raised. And yet they covertly
struck at Origen as the source of the Arian heresy: for, in condemning
those who deny the Son to be of the substance of the Father, they have
condemned Origen as much as Arius. On the ground taken by these persons
we have no right to condemn Valentine, The founder of a
Gnostic sect in the second century. He taught first in Egypt and
afterwards in Rome.
Marcion, See note on Letter
XLVIII. § 2. or the Cataphrygians, The Montanists
were so called because the headquarters of their sect were at Pepuza a
small village in Phrygia. or Manichæus, none of whom are
named by the council of Nicæa, and yet there is no doubt that in
time they were prior to it. But when they find themselves pressed
either to subscribe or to leave the Church, you may see some strange
twisting. They qualify their words, they arrange them anew, they use
vague expressions; so as, if possible, to hold both our confession and
that of our opponents, to be called indifferently heretics and
Catholics. As if it were not in the same spirit that the Delphian
Apollo (or, as he is sometimes called, Loxias) gave his oracles to Crœsus and to Pyrrhus; cheating
with a similar device two men widely separated in time. Crœsus when
he asked whether he should resist Cyrus was told that, if he did so, he
would overthrow a mighty kingdom, a prophecy fulfilled in his own
destruction; while Pyrrhus long afterwards received an equally evasive
answer in the words, “Pyrrhus the Sons of Rome may well
defeat.” To make my meaning clear I will give a
few examples.