22
most nearly akin to Protestantism, are the later and more mature parts of his system, and
that just these found great acceptance with the laity. The Pelagian controversy, in which he
developed his anthropology, marks the culmination of his theological and ecclesiastical career,
and his latest writings were directed against the Pelagian Julian and the Semi-Pelagians in
Gaul, who were brought to his notice by two friendly laymen, Prosper and Hilary. These
anti-Pelagian works have wrought mightily, it is most true, upon the Catholic church, and
have held in check the Pelagianizing tendencies of the hierarchical and monastic system,
but they have never passed into its blood and marrow. They waited for a favourable future,
and nourished in silence an opposition to the prevailing system.
In the middle age the better sects, which attempted to simplify, purify, and spiritualize
the reigning Christianity by return to the Holy Scriptures, and the Reformers before the
Reformation, such as Wiclif, Hus, Wessel, resorted most, after the apostle Paul, to the
bishop of Hippo as the representative of the doctrine of free grace.
The Reformers were led by his writings into a deeper understanding of Paul, and so
prepared for their great vocation. No church teacher did so much to mould Luther and
Calvin; none furnished them so powerful weapons against the dominant Pelagianism and
formalism; none is so often quoted by them with esteem and love.70
70 Luther pronounced upon the church fathers (with whom, however, excepting Augustin, he was but slightly
acquainted) very condemnatory judgments, even upon Basil, Chrysostom, and Jerome (for Jerome he had a
downright antipathy, on account of his advocacy of fasts, virginity, and monkery); he was at times dissatisfied
even with Augustin, because he after all did not find in him his sola fide, his articulus stantis vel cadentis ecclesiæ,
and says of him: “Augustin often erred; he cannot be trusted. Though he was good and holy, yet he, as well as
other fathers, was wanting in the true faith.” But this cursory utterance is overborne by numerous commendations;
and all such judgments of Luther must be taken cum grano salis. He calls Augustin the most pious, grave, and
sincere of the fathers, and the patron of divines, who taught a pure doctrine and submitted it in Christian humility
to the Holy Scriptures, etc., and he thinks, if he had lived in the sixteenth century, he would have been a Protestant
(si hoc seculo viveret, nobiscum sentiret), while Jerome would have gone with Rome. Compare his singular but
striking judgments on the fathers in Lutheri Colloquia, ed. H. E. Bindseil, 1863, tom. iii. 149, and many other
places. Gangauf, a Roman Catholic (a pupil of the philosopher Günther), concedes (l. c. p. 28, note 13) that
Luther and Calvin built their doctrinal system mainly on Augustin, but, as he correctly thinks, with only partial
right. Nourrisson, likewise a Roman Catholic, derives Protestantism from a corrupted (!) Augustinianism, and
very superficially makes Lutheranism and Calvinism essentially to consist in the denial of the freedom of the
will, which was only one of the questions of the Reformation. “On ne saurait le méconnaître, de l’Augustinianisme
corrompu, mais enfin de l’Augustinianisme procède le Protestantisme. Car, sans parler de Wiclif et de Huss, qui,
nourris de saint Augustin, soutiennent, avec le réalisme platonicien, la doctrine de la prédestination: Luther et
Calvin ne font guère autre chose, dans leurs principaux ouvrages, que cultiver des semences d’Augustinianisme”
(l. c. ii. p. 176). But the Reformation is far more, of course, than a repristination of an old controversy; it is a
44
The Influence of St. Augustin on Posterity, and His Relation to Catholicism…