19. That holy man and eloquent bishop Augustin not long
ago wrote to Marcellinus
was the lay imperial commissioner appointed to superintend the
discussion between the Catholics and Donatists at the Council of
Carthage, a.d. 411. In 413 Heraclian, governor
of Africa, revolted against Honorius, the Emperor, and invaded Italy.
The enterprise failed, and on his return to Africa the promoter of it
was put to death. The Donatists, called by Jerome
“heretics,” are supposed to have accused Marcellinus of
taking part in the rebellion. He was executed in 414.Marcellinus
(the same that was afterwards, though innocent, put to death by
heretics on the pretext of his taking part in the tyranny of
Heraclian “On the
Deserts and Remission of Sins, and the Baptism of Infants,” in
three books, the earliest of S. Augustin’s Anti-Pelagian
treatises. It was composed in reply to a letter from his friend
Marcellinus, who was harassed by Pelagianising disputants. See S. Aug.
“De Gest. Pel.” § 25.) two treatises on infant
baptism, in opposition to your heresy which maintains that infants are
baptized not for remission of sins, but for admission to the kingdom of
heaven, according as it is written in the Gospel, S. John iii. 3. “Except a man be born again of
water and of the Spirit, he cannot enter into the kingdom of
heaven.” He addressed a The “De
Spiritu et Littera.” Marcellinus found a difficulty in
Augustin’s view of the question of sinlessness. See
Bright’s Anti-Pelagian Treatises, Introduction, p. xix.third,
moreover, to the same Marcellinus, against those who say as do you,
that a man can be free from sin, if he chooses, without the help of
God. And, recently, a Whether he
who was made Bishop of Arles, in 429, is disputed. The treatise was the
“De Natura et Gratia,” written early in 415.fourth to
Hilary against this doctrine of yours, which is full of perversity. And
he is said to have others on the anvil with special regard to you,
which have not yet come to hand. Wherefore, I think I must abandon my
task, for fear Horace’s words may be thrown at me, Sat. i.
10.“Don’t carry firewood
into a forest.” For we must either say the same as he does, and
that would be superfluous; or, if we wished to say something fresh, we
should Or,
better positions have been occupied.find our best points anticipated
by that splendid genius. One thing I will say and so end my discourse,
that you ought either to give us a new creed, so that, after baptizing
children into the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit, you may
baptize them into the kingdom of heaven; or, if you have one baptism
both for infants and for persons of mature age, it follows that infants
also should be baptized for the remission of sins after the likeness of
the transgression of Adam. But if you think the remission of another’s sins implies injustice,
and that he has no need of it who could not sin, cross over to Origen,
your special favourite, who says that ancient offences Origen held
the pre-existence of souls, endowed with free will, and supposed their
condition in this world to be the result of their conduct in their
previous state of probation. committed long before in the heavens
are loosed in baptism. You will then be not only led by his authority
in other matters, but will be following his error in this also.