Sir William Palmer’s argument (A Treatise on
the Church of Christ, Pt. IV., Chapter X., Sect. IV.) is one of
much greater force, and needs an answer. He points out how, long
after the Council of Nice, the number of the General Councils was still
spoken of as being Six, and that in some instances this council is
referred to as the “pseudo” General Council of Nice.
Now at first sight this argument seems to be of great force. But
upon further consideration it will be seen to be after all of no great
weight. We may not be able to explain, nor are we called upon to
do so, why in certain cases writers chose still to speak of Six instead
of Seven General Councils, but we would point out that the same
continuance of the old expression can be found with regard to others of
the General Councils. For example, St. Gregory the Great says
that he “revered the four Ecumenical Councils as he did the four
Gospels,” but the fifth Ecumenical Synod had been held a number
of years before. Will anyone pretend from this to draw the
conclusion that at that time the Ecumenical character of the Fifth
Synod (II. Constantinople) was not recognized at Rome? Moreover,
among the instances cited (and there are but a very few all told) one
of them is fatal to the argument. For if Pope Hadrian in 871
still speaks of only six Ecumenical Synods, he omits two (according to
Roman count), for this date is after the synod which deposed
Photius—a synod rejected indeed afterwards by the Greeks, but
always accepted by the Latins as the Eighth of the Ecumenical
Councils. Would Sir William pretend for an instant that Hadrian
and the Church of Rome did not recognize that Council as Ecumenical and
as the Eighth Synod? He could not, for on page 208 he ingenuously
confesses that that Council “had been approved and confirmed by
that Pope.”