As a theologian Leo is thoroughly Western in type,
being not speculative but dogmatic: no one was better suited in
God’s Providence to give the final
completeness to the Church’s Doctrine of the Incarnation than
this clear-sighted, unimaginative, and persistent bishop of Rome.
His theological position on the cardinal doctrines of the Faith is
identical with that of the Athanasian symbol, to the language of which
his own language often bears a close resemblance. With his theory
of the Pope as universal Ruler of the Church in virtue of his being the
successor of S. Peter, the vast majority of English-speaking people
will have but little sympathy: and yet it can but be admired from
an objective standpoint as a bold, grand, and almost original Milman attributes the
real initiation of the Papal theory to the imperious Innocent I., who
held the See of Rome at the beginning of the fifth century
(402–417). conception. And there are no doubt
many smaller points of detail in his writings connected more with
discipline than with doctrine, which will now be reckoned if not as
actually objectionable, at least as arising from forgotten needs or
belonging to a byegone system: among these may be instanced his
objection to slaves as clergy and to the celebration of the Eucharist
more than once in one day except on festivals, where the church is too
small to hold all the worshippers at once: his advocacy of the
innovation of private instead of public confession for ordinary
penitents, and on the other hand his insisting on the old rule that
baptism should be administered only twice a year (at Easter and at
Whitsuntide): and again the somewhat undue prominence that he
gives to fasting and almsgiving as being on a level with prayer for
Lenten or Ember exercises, and to the intercessions of the
saints—particularly of the patron saints of Rome, SS. Peter,
Paul, and Lawrence. And yet at the same time there is very much
more to
be thankful
for as instructive than to object to as obsolete or dangerous.
For on the negative side we have no trace after all of the later direct
invocation of the saints, nor of the modern cultus of the B.V.M.
and of relics, while among the many positive good points in his
teaching must be reckoned his most proper theory of a bishop as not
only the channel of divine grace in virtue of ordination
(sacerdos) but also the overseer of the flock
(episcopus), in virtue of the people’s choice
and approval, which is essential to his office; his strong condemnation
of the practice of usury in laity as well as clergy; his high
appreciation of corporate even more than individual action among the
faithful; the thoroughly practical view he always puts before us of the
Christian life; and above all the “singularly Christian”
character of all his sermons, in which Christ is the Alpha and Omega of
all his thoughts and of all his exhortations. These are some of
the benefits which Leo has conferred upon the Church, and which have
rightfully earned for him the title “Great.”