Chapter 14.—19. Nor is it material, when we are considering the question of the
genuineness and holiness of the sacrament, "what the recipient of the sacrament believes,
and with what faith he is imbued." It is of the very highest consequence as regards the en-
trance into salvation, but is wholly immaterial as regards the question of the sacrament.
For it is quite possible that a man may be possessed of the genuine sacrament and a corrupted
faith, as it is possible that he may hold the words of the creed in their integrity, and yet en-
tertain an erroneous belief about the Trinity, or the resurrection, or any other point. For it
is no slight matter, even within the Catholic Church itself, to hold a faith entirely consistent
with the truth about even God Himself, to say nothing of any of His creatures. Is it then to
be maintained, that if any one who has been baptized within the Catholic Church itself
should afterwards, in the course of reading, or by listening to instruction, or by quiet argu-
ment, find out, through God’s own revelation, that he had before believed otherwise than
he ought, it is requisite that he should therefore be baptized afresh? But what carnal and
natural man is there who does not stray through the vain conceits1289 of his own heart, and
picture God’s nature to himself to be such as he has imagined out of his carnal sense, and
differ from the true conception of God as far as vanity from truth? Most truly, indeed,
speaks the apostle, filled with the light of truth: "The natural man," says he, "receiveth not
the things of the Spirit of God."1290 And yet herein he was speaking of men whom he
himself shows to have been baptized. For he says to them, "Was Paul crucified for you? or
were ye baptized in the name of Paul?"1291 These men had therefore the sacrament of
baptism; and yet, inasmuch as their wisdom was of the flesh, what could they believe about
God otherwise than according to the perception of their flesh, according to which "the nat-
ural man receiveth not the things of the Spirit of God?" To such he says: "I could not speak
unto you as unto spiritual, but as unto carnal, even as unto babes in Christ. I have fed you
with milk, and not with meat: for hitherto ye were not able to bear it, neither yet now are
ye able. For ye are yet carnal."1292 For such are carried about with every wind of doctrine,
of which kind he says, "That we be no more children, tossed to and fro, and carried about
with every wind of doctrine."1293 It is then true that, if these men shall have advanced even
to the spiritual age of the inner man, and in the integrity of understanding shall have learned
how far different from the requirements of the truth has been the belief which they have
been led by the fallacious character of their conceits to entertain of God, they are therefore
to be baptized again? For, on this principle, it would be possible for a Catholic catechumen
1289 Phantasmata.
1290 1 Cor ii. 14.
1291 1 Cor. i. 13.
1292 1 Cor iii. 1-3.
1293 Eph. iv. 14.
Chapter 14
768
Chapter 14