4. Whence did it occur to you, sirs, to say that
the Body is of one Essence with the Godhead of the Word? For it is well
to begin at this point, in order that by shewing this opinion to be
unsound, all the others too may be proved to be the same. Now from the
divine Scriptures we discover nothing of the kind. For they say that
God came in a human body. But the fathers who also assembled at
Nicæa say that, not the body, but the Son Himself is coessential
with the Father, and that while He is of the Essence of the Father, the
body, as they admitted according to the Scriptures, is of Mary. Either
then deny the Synod of Nicæa, and as heretics bring in your
doctrine from the side; or, if you wish to be children of the fathers,
do not hold the contrary of what they wrote. For here again you may see
how monstrous it is: If the Word is coessential with the body which is
of earthly nature, while the Word is, by your own confession,
coessential with the Father, it will follow that even the Father
Himself is coessential with the body produced from the earth. And why
any longer blame the Arians for calling the Son a creature, when you go
off to another form of impiety, saying that the Word was changed into
flesh and bones and hair and muscles and all the body, and was altered
from its own nature? For it is time for you to say openly that He was
born of earth; for from earth is the nature of the bones and of all the
body. What then is this great folly of yours, that you fight even with
one another? For in saying that the Word is coessential with the Body,
you distinguish the one from the other ἕτερον πρὸς
ἕτερον
σημαίνετε,
while in saying that He has been changed into flesh, you imagine a
change of the Word Himself. And who will tolerate you any longer if you
so much as utter these opinions? For you have gone further in impiety
than any heresy. For if the Word is coessential with the Body, the
commemoration and the work of Mary are superfluous Letter 61, §3., inasmuch as the body could have existed
before Mary, just as the Word also is eternal: if, that is, it is as
you say co-essential with the Body. Or what need was there even of the
Word coming among us, to put on what was coessential with Himself,
or to change His own nature and
become a body? For the Deity does not take hold Heb. ii. 16. of
itself, so as to put on what is of its own Essence, any more than the
Word sinned, in that it ransoms the sins of others, in order that
changing into a body it should offer itself a sacrifice for itself, and
ransom itself.