2/8
JEROME.
" the good that I would, I do not ; the evil
which I would not, that I do." ' What necessity fetters his will ? What compulsion commands him to do what he dislikes ? And
why must he do not what he wishes but what he dislikes and does not wish ? He will
answer you thus : " nay, but, O man, who art thou that replies! against God ? Shall the
thing formed say unto him that formed it,
Why hast thou made me thus ? Hath not the
potter power over the clay, of the same lump to make one vessel unto honour and another
unto dishonour ? " a Bring a yet graver charge against God and ask Him why, when
Esau and Jacob were still in the womb, He
said : " Jacob have I loved, but Esau have I
hated." : Accuse Him of injustice because, when Achan the son of Carmi stole part of
the spoil of Jericho, He butchered so many
thousands for the fault of one.4 Ask Him why for the sin of the sons of Eli the people were
well-nigh annihilated and the ark captured.6 And why, when David sinned by numbering
the people, so many thousands lost their
lives.6 Or lastly make your own the favorite cavil of your associate Porphyry, and ask how
God can be described as pitiful and of great
mercy when from Adam to Moses and from
Moses to the coming of Christ He has suf-
fered all nations to die in ignorance of the
Law and of His commandments.7 For
Britain, that province so fertile in despots,
the Scottish tribes, and all the barbarians
round about as far as the ocean were alike
without knowledge of Moses and the prophets.
Why should Christ's coming have been delayed to the last times ? Why should He not have come before so vast a number had
perished ? Of this last question the blessed
apostle in writing to the Romans most wisely
disposes by admitting that he does not know
and that only God does. Do you too, then,
condescend to remain ignorant of that into
which you inquire. Leave to God His power
over what is His own ; He does not need you
to justify His actions. I am the hapless
being against whom you ought to direct your
insults, I who am for ever reading the words :
" by grace ye are saved," 8 and " blessed is he whose transgression is forgiven, whose sin is
covered." * Yet, to lay bare my own weak- ness, I know that I wish to do many things
which I ought to do and yet cannot. For
while my spirit is strong and leads me to life
my flesh is weak and draws me to death.
And I have the warning of the Lord in my
ears : " watch and pray that ye enter not
1 Rom. vii. 19. * Rom. ix. 20, 21. 3 Mai. i. 2, 3. Rom. ix. 13. 4 Josh. vii. * i Sam. iv. 6 2 Sam. xxiv.
7 This objection is dealt with at length by Augustine (Letter CXI. §§ 8-15. See Vol. I. Series I. of this Library).
6 Eph. ii. 5. » ps. xxxii. i.
into temptation. The spirit indeed is willing,
but the flesh is weak." ' 10. It is in vain that you misrepresent me
and try to convince the ignorant that I con- demn free will. Let him who condemns it be
himself condemned. We have been created
endowed with free will ; still it is not this
which distinguishes us from the brutes. For
human free will, as I have said before, de-
pends upon the help of God and needs His
aid moment by moment, a thing which you
and yours do not choose to admit. Your
position is that, if a man once has free will,
he no longer needs the help of God. It is
true that freedom of the will brings with it
freedom of decision. Still man does not act
immediately on his free will, but requires
God's aid who Himself needs no aid. You
yourself boast that a man's righteousness
may be perfect and equal to God's ; yet you confess that you are a sinner. Answer me
this, then ; do you or do you not wish to be
free from sin ? If you do, why on your
principle do you not carry out your desire ?
And if you do not, do you not prove your-
self a despiser of God's commandments ? If you are a despiser, then you are a sinner.
And if you are a sinner, then the scripture
says : " unto the wicked God saith, what hast thou to do to declare my statutes, or that thou
shouldest take my covenant in thy mouth ?
seeing thou hatest instruction and castest
my words behind thee."a So long as you are unwilling to do what God commands, so
long do you cast His words behind you. And
yet like a new apostle you lay down for the world what to do and what not to do.
However, your words and your thoughts by
no means correspond. For when you say that
you are a sinner — yet that a man may be with-
out sin if he will, you wish it to be under-
stood that you are a saint and free from all
sin. It is only out of humility 3 that you call yourself a sinner ; to give you a chance of
praising others while you depreciate yourself.
11. Another of your arguments is also in-
tolerable, one which runs thus : " To be sinless is one thing, to be able to be so is another.
The first is not in our power, the second gen-
erally is. For though none ever has been
sinless, yet, if a man wills to be so, he can
be so." What sort of reasoning, I ask, is this ? that a man can be what a man never
has been ! that a thing is possible which
according to your own admission, no man
has yet achieved ! You are predicating of
man a quality which, for aught you know, he
may never possess ! and you are assigning to
any chance person a grace which you cannot
1 Matt. xxvi. 41. a Ps. 1. 16, 17. * Or rather, mock humility.