50. If then any think of other beginning, and
other Father, considering the equality of these attributes, it is a mad
thought. But if, since the Son is from the Father, all that is the
Father’s is the Son’s as in an image and Expression, let it
be considered dispassionately, whether an essence foreign from the
Father’s essence admit of
such attributes; and whether such a one be other in nature and alien in
essence, and not coessential with the Father. For we must take reverent
heed, lest transferring what is proper to the Father to what is unlike
Him in essence, and expressing the Father’s godhead by what is
unlike in kind and alien in essence, we introduce another essence
foreign to Him, yet capable of the properties of the first essence Arianism was in the dilemma of denying Christ’s divinity, or
introducing a second God. The Arians proper went off on the former side
of the alternative, the Semi-Arians on the latter; and Athan., as here
addressing the Semi Arians, insists on the greatness of the latter
error. This of course was the objection which attached to the
words ὁμοιούσιον,
ἀπαράλλακτος
εἴκων, &c., when
disjoined from the ὁμοούσιον; and Eusebius’s language, supr. p. 75, note 7,
shews us that it is not an imaginary one., and lest we be silenced by God Himself,
saying, ‘My glory I will not give to another,’ and be
discovered worshipping this alien God, and be accounted such as were
the Jews of that day, who said, ‘Wherefore dost Thou, being a
man, make Thyself God?’ referring, the while, to another source
the things of the Spirit, and blasphemously saying, ‘He casteth
out devils through Beelzebub’ (Isa. xlii. 8; John x. 33; Luke xi. 15). But if this is shocking, plainly
the Son is not unlike in essence, but coessential with the Father; for
if what the Father has is by nature the Son’s, and the Son
Himself is from the Father, and because of this oneness of godhead and
of nature He and the Father are one, and He that hath seen the Son hath
seen the Father, reasonably is He called by the Fathers
‘Coessential;’ for to what is other in essence, it belongs
not to possess such prerogatives.