Plinius Cæcilius Secundus, commonly called “Pliny the
younger” to distinguish him from his uncle, Plinius Secundus the
elder, was a man of great literary attainments and an intimate friend
of the Emperor Trajan. Of his literary remains the most important are
his epistles, collected in ten books. The epistle of which Eusebius
speaks in this chapter is No. 96 (97), and the reply of Trajan No. 97
(98) of the tenth book. The epistle was written from Bithynia, probably
within a year after Pliny became governor there, which was in 110 or
111. It reads as follows: “It is my custom, my Lord, to refer to
thee all questions concerning which I am in doubt; for who can better
direct my hesitation or instruct my ignorance? I have never been
present at judicial examinations of the Christians; therefore I am
ignorant how and to what extent it is customary to punish or to search
for them. And I have hesitated greatly as to whether any distinction
should be made on the ground of age, or whether the weak should be
treated in the same way as the strong; whether pardon should be granted
to the penitent, or he who has ever been a Christian gain nothing by
renouncing it; whether the mere name, if unaccompanied with crimes, or
crimes associated with the name, should be punished. Meanwhile, with
those who have been brought before me as Christians I have pursued the
following course. I have asked them if they were Christians, and if
they have confessed, I have asked them a second and third time,
threatening them with punishment; if they have persisted, I have
commanded them to be led away to punishment. For I did not doubt that
whatever that might be which they confessed, at any rate pertinacious
and inflexible obstinacy ought to be punished. There have been others
afflicted with like insanity who as Roman citizens I have decided
should be sent to Rome. In the course of the proceedings, as commonly
happens, the crime was extended, and many varieties of cases appeared.
An anonymous document was published, containing the names of many
persons. Those who denied that they were or had been Christians I
thought ought to be released, when they had followed my example in
invoking the gods and offering incense and wine to thine
image,—which I had for that purpose ordered brought with the
images of the gods,—and when they had besides cursed
Christ—things which they say that those who are truly Christians
cannot be compelled to do. Others, accused by an informer, first said
that they were Christians and afterwards denied it, saying that they
had indeed been Christians, but had ceased to be, some three years,
some several years, and one even twenty years before. All adored thine
image and the statues of the gods, and cursed Christ. Moreover, they
affirmed that this was the sum of their guilt or error; that they had
been accustomed to come together on a fixed day before daylight and to
sing responsively a song unto Christ as God; and to bind themselves
with an oath, not with a view to the commission of some crime, but, on
the contrary, that they would not commit theft, nor robbery, nor
adultery, that they would not break faith, nor refuse to restore a
deposit when asked for it. When they had done these things, their
custom was to separate and to assemble again to partake of a meal,
common yet harmless (which is not the characteristic of a nefarious
superstition); but this they had ceased to do after my edict, in which
according to thy demands I had prohibited fraternities. I therefore
considered it the more necessary to examine, even with the use of
torture, two female slaves who were called deaconesses
(ministræ), in order to ascertain the truth. But I found
nothing except a superstition depraved and immoderate; and therefore,
postponing further inquiry, I have turned to thee for advice. For the
matter seems to me worth consulting about, especially on account of the
number of persons involved. For many of every age and of every rank and
of both sexes have been already, and will be brought to trial. For the
contagion of this superstition has permeated not only the cities, but
also the villages and even the country districts. Yet it can apparently
be arrested and corrected. At any rate, it is certainly a fact that the
temples, which were almost deserted, are now beginning to be
frequented, and the sacred rites, which were for a long time
interrupted, to be resumed, and fodder for the victims to be sold, for
which previously hardly a purchaser was to be found. From which it is
easy to gather how great a multitude of men may be reformed if there is
given a chance for repentance.”
The reply of
Trajan—commonly called “Trajan’s
Rescript”—reads as follows: “Thou hast followed the
right course, my Secundus, in treating the cases of those who have been
brought before thee as Christians. For no fixed rule can be laid down
which shall be applicable to all cases. They are not to be searched
for; if they are accused and convicted, they are to be punished;
nevertheless, with the proviso that he who denies that he is a
Christian, and proves it by his act (re ipsa),—i.e. by
making supplication to our gods,—although suspected in regard to
the past, may by repentance obtain pardon. Anonymous accusations ought
not to be admitted in any proceedings; for they are of most evil
precedent, and are not in accord with our age.”