2. To what does all this tend, you ask. I reply; you
remember the question that you proposed. It was this. A Spanish bishop
named Carterius, old in years and in the priesthood has married two
wives, one before he was baptized, and, she having died, another since
he has passed through the laver; and you are of opinion that he has
violated the precept of the apostle, who in his list of episcopal
qualifications commands that a bishop shall be “the husband of
one wife.” 1 Tim. iii. 2. I am surprised
that you have pilloried an individual when the whole world is filled
with persons ordained in similar circumstances; I do not mean
presbyters or clergy of lower rank, but speak only of bishops of whom
if I were to enumerate them all one by one I should gather a sufficient
number to surpass the crowd which attended the synod of Ariminum. This synod held in
359 a.d. was attended by about 450 bishops. It
put forth an Arian formula which caused general consternation.
“The whole world,” says Jerome, “groaned and was
astonished to find itself Arian.” Still it does not become me to defend one
by incriminating many; nor if reason condemns a sin, to make the number
of those who commit it an excuse for it. At Rome an eloquent pleader
caught me, as the phrase goes, between the horns of a dilemma:
whichever way I turned I was held fast. Is it sinful, said he, to marry
a wife, or is it not sinful? I in my simplicity, not being wary enough
to avoid the snare laid for me, replied that it was not sinful. Then he
propounded another question: Is it good deeds which are done away with
in baptism or is it evil? Here again my simplicity induced me to say
that it was sins which were forgiven. At this point, just as I began to
fancy myself secure, the horns of the dilemma commenced to close in on
me from this side and from that and their points hidden before began to
shew themselves. If, said he, to marry a wife is not sinful, and if
baptism forgives sins, all that is not done away with is held over. On
the instant a dark mist rose before my eyes as though I had been struck
by a strong boxer. Yet recalling the sophism attributed to
Chrysippus: See note on Letter
LXI. 3. “Whether you lie or whether
you speak the truth, in either case you lie,” I came to myself
again and turned upon my opponent with a dilemma of my own. Pray tell
me, I said, does baptism make a new man or does it not? He grudgingly
admitted that it did. I pursued my advantage by saying, Does it make
him wholly new or only partially so? He replied, Wholly. Then I asked,
Is there nothing then of the old man held over in baptism? He assented.
Hereupon I propounded the argument; If baptism makes a man new and
creates a wholly new being, and if there is nothing of the old man held
over in the new, that which once was in the old cannot be imputed to
the new. At first my thorny friend held his tongue; afterwards however,
making Piso’s mistake, Cf. Cic. In Pis.
1. though he had
nothing to say he could not remain silent. Sweat stood upon his brow,
his cheeks turned pale, his lips trembled, his tongue clove to his
mouth, his throat became dry; and fear (not age) made him cower. At
last he broke out in these words, Have you not read how the apostle
permits none to be ordained priest save the husband of one wife, and
that what he lays stress upon is the fact of the marriage and not the
time at which it is contracted? Now as the fellow had challenged me
with syllogisms, and as I saw that he was feeling his way towards some
intricate and awkward questions, I proceeded to turn his own weapons
against him. I said therefore, Whom did the apostle select for the
episcopate, baptized persons or catechumens? He refused to reply. I however made a fresh onslaught
repeating my question a second time and a third. You would have taken
him for Niobe changed to stone by excessive weeping. I turned to the
audience and said: It is all the same to me, good people, whether I
bind my opponent awake or sleeping; but it is easier to fetter a man
who offers no resistance. If those whom the apostle admits into the
ranks of the clergy are not catechumens but the faithful, and if he who
is ordained bishop is always one of the faithful, being one of the
faithful he cannot have the faults of a catechumen imputed to him. Such
were the darts I hurled at my paralysed opponent. Such the quivering
spears I cast at him. At last his mouth opened and he vomited forth the
contents of his mind. Certainly, he blurted out, that is the doctrine
of the apostle Paul.