For instance, the argument taken from the whole nation of Israel being called God’s
521
people, and every thing that Mr. W. alleges, pertaining to this matter, is in like manner
against his own scheme as against mine: and that, let the question be what it will; whether
it be about the qualifications which make it lawful for the church to admit, or about the
lawfulness of persons coming to sacraments; whether it be about the profession they should
make before men, or the internal qualification they must have in the sight of God. And what
Mr. W. says to the contrary, does not at all deliver the argument from this embarrassment
and absurdity. After all he has said, the argument, if any thing related to the controversy, is
plainly this, That because the whole nation of Israel were God’s visible people, (which is the
same as visible saints,) therefore the scripture notion of visible saintship is of larger extent
than mine; and the Scripture supposes those to be visible saints, which my scheme does not
suppose to be so.
But if this be Mr. W. s argument, then let us see whether it agrees any better with his
own scheme. Mr. Blake (Mr. W.‘s great author) in his book on the Covenant,(p. 190. b.) insists,
that Israel at the very worst is owned as God’s covenant people, and were called God’s people;
and (p. 149. e.) that all the congregation of Israel, and every one of them, are called holy,
and God’s own people, even Korah and his company.—And (p. 253. e. 254. a.) he urges,
that every one who is descended from Jacob, even the worst of Israel, in their lowest state
and condition, were God’s people in covenant, called by the name of God’s people. And Mr.
W. herein follows Mr. Blake, and urges the same thing; that this nation was God’s covenant
people, and were called God’s people, at the time that they were carried captive into Babylon,
(p. 24. d.) when they were undoubtedly at their worst, more corrupt than at any other time
we read of in the Old Testament; being represented by the prophets, as overrun with abom-
inable idolatries, and other kinds of the most gross, heaven-daring impieties, most obstinate,
abandoned, pertinacious, and irreclaimable in their rebellion against God, and against his
word by his prophets. But yet these, it is urged, are called the people of God; not agreeable
to my notion of visible saintship, but agreeable to Mr. W.‘s. What his notion of visible saints
is, he tells us in p. 139. He there says expressly, that he “does not suppose persons to be visible
saints, unless they exhibit a credible profession and visibility of gospel-holiness.“ Now do
those things said about those vile wretches in Israel, agree with this? Did they exhibit moral
evidence of gospel-holiness?—But if we bring the matter lower still, and say, the true notion
of visible saintship is a credible appearance and moral evidence of moral sincerity; does this
flagrant, open, abandoned, obstinate impiety consist with moral evidence of such sincerity
as that? It is as apparent therefore, in Mr. W.‘s scheme as mine, that when these are called
God’s people, it is in some other sense than that wherein the members of the christian church
are called visible saints. And indeed the body of the nation of Israel, in those corrupt times,
were so far from being God’s church of visibly pious persons, visibly endowed with gospel-
holiness, that that people, as to the body of them, were visibly and openly declared by God,
2004
SECTION XI. Arguments hostile to both sides