between husband and wife. I do not now pretend to determine of what sort this union is;
nor is it necessary to my present purpose to enter into any manner of disputes about it. If
any are disgusted at the word union, as obscure and unintelligible, the word relation equally
serves my purpose. I do not now desire to determine any more about it, than all, of all sorts,
will readily allow, viz. that there is a peculiar relation between true Christians and Christ,
which there is not between him and others; and which is signified by those metaphorical
expressions in Scripture, of being in Christ, being members of Christ, &c. 472
life. There are some indeed that seem to be grafted into Christ by an outward profession of Christianity, who
yet derive no influence from him, so as to bring forth fruit, because they are not vitally united to him”—Dr.
Tillotson in his 3rd vol. of Serm., p. 307 By this it appears that the vital union between Christ and true Christians,
which is much more of a mystery than the relative union, and necessarily implies it, was not thought an unreas-
onable doctrine by one of the greatest divines on the other side of the question in hand.
472 The word “union,” in this connexion, is both more intelligible and more appropriate, than the word relation;
since in this connexion the latter is the consequence of the former. As the doctrine of a vital union to Christ is
fundamentally important in Christianity, and inseparable from the doctrine of justification; and as our author
passes it over with so much brevity, a few observations upon it in this place may appear the more needful. 1.
The Scriptures are not only full of the fact, but they abound with illustrations of it. The first part of John xv. is
full and explicit to this purpose. 2. What the Scriptures assert, and illustrate, is abundantly corroborated by the
reasonableness of the thing. To suppose the reality of vital religion without a corresponding vital union, is to
suppose an important effect without as adequate cause, as shall be further shown 3. The question then is, What
is the immediate cause of this vital union? Now as the union subsisting is between the Spirit of Christ, and man,
the immediate cause must be in the one or the other of these, or in both at the same instant, or in neither. If the
immediate cause be in man, he makes his approach to Christ either as a carnal or spiritual man, for these is no
conceivable medium. But the idea of a carnal man uniting himself to Christ in order to form a vital union, is
both unscriptural and unreasonable. It is unscriptural; for the scripture asserts that “The carnal mind is enmity
against God;” how then can it be the cause of a vital union? “Of him are ye in Christ Jesus; ”—” and you hath
he quickened, who were dead in trespasses and sins; ”—it is not therefore the carnal man that unites himself to
Christ, or quickens himself in order to effect it. It is also unreasonable; for it supposes a glorious effect without
an adequate cause. The effect is spiritual, while the cause is carnal, which are not only different but even directly
opposite. What ideas can be more contradictory, or sentiment more unreasonable? 4. The supposition of two
simultaneous causes, the one being the Spirit of Christ, and the other the carnal man, involves the same incon-
sistency. For how can the mere circumstance of time, irrespective of causal influence, make any difference? If
the carnal mind be adequate to unite itself to Christ at one time, why not at another time as well, except some
causal influence makes the difference? For surely no one can suppose that some individual moment of time, as
distinguished from others preceding, constitutes the cause of difference. powerful, the quickening, and uniting
presence, the vital and 5 To suppose a spiritual man whether by the exercise of his faith or by any other mental
act, in the cause of a vital union, is no less inconsistent than the former supposition. For how can he be a spir-
itual man, without a spiritual casual influence? But if such influence be admitted as a predisposing cause of his
2294
DISCOURSE. I. Justification by Faith alone.