different in order though no doubt their contents were similar. The differing views of
Petavius and Walch will be found in full in Hefele (§ 401).
In concluding his masterly treatment of this whole matter, Hefele makes (§ 402) a remark
well worthy of repetition in this place:
“The great friendship which Charles shewed to Pope Hadrian down to the hour of his
death proves that their way of thinking with regard to the cultus of images was not so opposite
as many suppose, and—above all—as many have tried to make out.”
I shall close this matter with the admirably learned and judicious words of Michaud.
“No doubt there had been abuses in connexion with the worship of images; but the
Council of Nice never approved of these. No doubt, too, certain marks of veneration used
in the East were not practised in Gaul; but the Council of Nice did not go into these partic-
ulars. It merely determined the principle, to wit, the lawfulness and moral necessity of
honouring the holy images; and in doing this it did not in any degree innovate. Charlemagne
ought to have known this, for, already in the sixth century Fortunatus, in his Poem on St.
Martin, tells how in Gaul they lighted lamps before the images.550 The great point that
Charlemagne made was that what was called in the West ‘adoration,’ in the strict sense (that
is to say the worship of Latria) should be rendered to none other than God; now this is exactly
the doctrine of the Council of Nice. Charlemagne himself admits that the learned may
venerate images, meaning thereby that the veneration is really addressed to the prototypes,
but that such veneration is a source of scandal to the ignorant who in the image venerate551
nothing but the material image itself (Lib. III., cap. xvj.).”552
550 “Here on the wall is an image of the Saint and under its feet a little window, and a lamp, in the glass bowl
of which the fire burns.” Fortun. (Migne., Pat. Lat., Tom. LXXXVIII.) De Vita S. Martin, Lib. iv., 690 (col. 426).
551 “And adore” in the Latin.
552 Michaud. Discussion sur les Sept Conciles Œcuméniques, p. 300.
1074
The Chief Cause of Trouble a Logomachy.