The great question of dispute between the church of Asia Minor and
the rest of Christendom was whether the paschal communion should be
celebrated on the fourteenth of Nisan, or on the Sunday of the
resurrection festival, without regard to Jewish chronology. The
Christians of Asia Minor, appealing to the example of the apostles,
John and Philip, and to the uniform practice of the Church, celebrated
the Christian passover always on the fourteenth of Nisan, whatever day
of the week that might be, by a solemn fast, and closed the day with
the communion in commemoration of the last paschal supper of Christ.
The Roman church, on the other hand, followed by all the rest of
Christendom, celebrated the death of Christ always on Friday, and his
resurrection on the Sunday following the first full moon after the
vernal equinox, and continued their paschal fast until the latter day.
It thus happened that the fast of the Asiatic Christians, terminating,
as it did, with the fourteenth of Nisan, often closed some days before
the fast of the other churches, and the lack of uniformity occasioned
great scandal. As Schaff says: “The gist of the paschal
controversy was whether the Jewish paschal day (be it a Friday or not)
or the Christian Sunday should control the idea and time of the entire
festival.” The former practice emphasized Christ’s death;
the latter his resurrection. The first discussion of the question took
place between Polycarp and Anicetus, bishop of Rome, when the former
was on a visit to that city, between 150 and 155. Irenæus gives an
account of this which is quoted by Eusebius in chap. 25. Polycarp clung
to the Asiatic practice of observing the 14th of Nisan, but could not
persuade Anicetus to do the same, nor could Anicetus persuade him not
to observe that day. They nevertheless communed together in Rome, and
separated in peace. About 170 a.d. the
controversy broke out again in Laodicea, the chief disputants being
Melito of Sardis and Apolinarius of Hierapolis (see above, Bk. IV.
chap. 26, note 1, and chap. 27, note 1). In this controversy Melito
advocated the traditional Asiatic custom of observing the fourteenth
day, while Apolinarius opposed it. To distinguish two parties of
Quartodecimans,—a Judaizing and a more orthodox,—as must be
done if Apolinarius is regarded, as he is by many, as a Quartodeciman,
is, as Schaff shows entirely unwarranted. We know only of the one
party, and Apolinarius did not belong to it. The third stage of the
controversy, which took place while Victor was bishop of Rome, in the
last decade of the second century, was much more bitter and important.
The leaders of the two sides were Polycrates, bishop of Ephesus, and
Victor, bishop of Rome,—the latter an overbearing man, who
believed that he, as Bishop of Rome, had a right to demand of all other
churches conformity to the practices of his own church. The controversy
came to an open rupture between the churches of Asia and that of Rome,
but other churches did not sympathize with the severe measures of
Victor, and the breach was gradually healed—just how and when we
do not know; but the Roman practice gradually prevailed over the
Asiatic, and finally, at the Council of Nicæa (325), was declared
binding upon the whole Church, while the old Asiatic practice was
condemned. This decision was acquiesced in by the bishops of Asia, as
well as by the rest of the world, and only scattered churches continued
to cling to the practice of the earlier Asiatics, and they were branded
as heretics, and called Quartodecimanians (from quarta decima),
a name which we carry back and apply to all who observed the fourteenth
day, even those of the second and third centuries. This brief summary
will enable us better to understand the accounts of Eusebius, who is
our chief authority on the subject. The paschal controversy has had an
important bearing upon the question of the authenticity of the fourth
Gospel, the Tübingen critics having drawn from this controversy
one of their strongest arguments against its genuineness. This subject
cannot be discussed here, but the reader is referred, for a brief
statement of the case, to Schaff’s Ch. Hist. II. 219. The
Johannine controversy has given rise to an extensive literature on
these paschal disputes. Among the most important’ works are
Hilgenfeld’s Der Paschastreit der alten Kirche nach seiner
Bedeutung fur die Kirchengesch. u. s. w.; and Schürer’s
Die Paschastreitigkeiten des zweiten Jahrhunderts, in the
Zeitschrift für hist. Theologie, 1870, p.
182–284,—the latter perhaps the ablest extended discussion
of the subject extant. The reader is also referred to the article
Easter, in Smith’s Dict. of Christ. Ant.; to
Hefele’s Conciliengesch. I. p. 86–101; and
especially to the chapter on the paschal controversies in
Schaff’s Ch. Hist. Vol. II. p. 209–220. This chapter
of Schaff’s is the clearest, and, in the opinion of the writer,
by far the most satisfactory, brief statement of the whole subject
which we have.