Chapter X.—Pantænus the Philosopher.
1. About that time, Pantænus,1505 a man highly distinguished for his learning, had
charge of the school of the faithful in Alexandria.1506 A school of sacred learning, which
1505 Pantænus is the first teacher of the Alexandrian school that is known to us, and even his life is involved
in obscurity. His chief significance for us lies in the fact that he was the teacher of Clement, with whom the Al-
exandrian school first steps out into the full light of history, and makes itself felt as a power in Christendom.
Another prominent pupil of Pantænus was Alexander, bishop of Jerusalem (see below, Bk. VI. chap. 14). Pantænus
was originally a Stoic philosopher, and must have discussed philosophy in his school in connection with theology,
for Origen appeals to him as his example in this respect (see below, Bk. VI. chap. 19). His abilities are testified
to by Clement (in his Hypotyposes; see the next chapter, §4), who speaks of him always in terms of the deepest
respect and affection. Of his birth and death we know nothing. Clement, Strom. I. 1, calls him a “Sicilian bee,”
which may, perhaps, have reference to his birthplace. The statement of Philip of Side, that he was an Athenian,
is worthless. We do not know when he began his work in Alexandria, nor when he finished it. But from Bk. VI.
chap. 6 we learn that Clement had succeeded Pantænus, and was in charge of the school in the time of Septimius
Severus. This probably means not merely that Pantænus had left Egypt, but that he was already dead; and if that
be the case, the statement of Jerome (de vir. ill. 36), that Pantænus was in charge of the school during the reigns
of Septimius Severus and Caracalla, is erroneous (Jerome himself expressly says, in ibid. chap. 38, that Clement
succeeded Pantænus upon the death of the latter). Jerome’s statement, however, that Pantænus was sent to India
by Demetrius, bishop of Alexandria, is not necessarily in conflict with the indefinite account of Eusebius, who
gives no dates. What authority Jerome has for his account we do not know. If his statement be correct, the
journey must have taken place after 190; and thus after, or in the midst or, his Alexandrian activity. Eusebius
apparently accepted the latter opinion, though his statement at the end of this chapter is dark, and evidently
implies that he was very uncertain in regard to the matter. His whole account rests simply on hearsay, and
therefore too much weight must not be laid upon its accuracy. After Clement comes upon the scene (which was
at least some years before the outbreak of the persecution of Severus, 200 a.d.—when he left the city) we hear
nothing more of Pantænus. Some have put his journey to India in this later period; but this is contrary to the
report of Eusebius, and there is no authority for the opinion. Photius (Cod. 118) records a tradition that Pantænus
had himself heard some of the apostles; but this is impossible, and is asserted by no one else. According to
Jerome, numerous commentaries of Pantænus were extant in his time. Eusebius, at the close of this chapter,
speaks of his expounding the Scriptures “both orally and in writing,” but he does not enumerate his works, and
apparently had never seen them. No traces of them are now extant, unless some brief reminiscences of his
teaching, which we have, are supposed to be drawn from his works, and not merely from his lectures or conver-
sations (see Routh, Rel. Sac. I. p. 375–383).
1506 The origin of this school of the faithful, or “catechetical school,” in Alexandria is involved in obscurity.
Philip of Side names Athenagoras as the founder of the school, but his account is full of inconsistencies and
contradictions, and deserves no credence. The school first comes out into the light of history at this time with
Pantænus at its head, and plays a prominent part in Church history under Clement, Origen, Heraclas, Dionysius,
Didymus, &c., until the end of the fourth century, when it sinks out of sight in the midst of the dissensions of
Pantænus the Philosopher.
525
Pantænus the Philosopher.