But with reference Oehler’s punctuation, while it does not exactly follow that
of the earlier editions, still seems to admit of emendation
here. to those who stumble at the idea of
“passion,” and on this ground maintain the diversity of the
Essences,—arguing that the Father, by reason of the exaltation of
His Nature, does not admit passion, and that the Son on the other hand
condescended, by reason of defect and divergence, to the partaking of
His sufferings,—I wish to add these remarks to what has been
already said:—That nothing is truly “passion” which
does not tend to sin, nor would one strictly call by the name of
“passion” the necessary routine of nature, regarding the
composite nature as it goes on its course in a kind of order and
sequence. For the mutual concurrence of heterogeneous elements in the
formation of our body is a kind of a combination harmoniously conjoined
out of several dissimilar elements; but when, at the due time, the tie
is loosed which bound together this concurrence of the elements, the
combined nature is once more dissolved into the elements of which it
was composed. This then is rather a work than a passion of the nature The
word πάθος, like the
English word “passion,” has a double sense: in one sense it
connotes a tendency to evil action or evil habit—and in this
sense Christ was not subject to passion. In another sense it has no
such connotation, and it is in this sense (a sense, Gregory would say,
somewhat inexact), that the term is used to express the sufferings of
Christ:—to this case, it may be said, the inexact use of the
English word is for the most part restricted.. For we give the name of
“passion” only to that which is opposed to the virtuous
unimpassioned state and of this we believe that He Who granted us
salvation was at all times devoid, Who “was in all points tempted
like as we are yet without sin Heb. iv. 15..” Of that, at
least, which is truly passion, which is a diseased condition of the
will, He was not a partaker; for it says “He did no sin, neither
was guile found in His mouth 1 Pet. ii. 22.”; but the
peculiar attributes of our nature, which, by a kind of customary abuse
of terms, are called by the same name of
“passion,”—of these, we confess, the Lord did
partake,—of birth, nourishment, growth, of sleep and toil, and
all those natural dispositions which the soul is wont to experience
with regard to bodily inconveniences,—the desire of that which is
lacking, when the longing passes from the body to the soul, the sense
of pain, the dread of death, and all the like, save only such as, if
followed, lead to sin. As, then, when we perceive His power extending
through all things in heaven, and air, and earth, and sea, whatever
there is in heaven, whatever there is beneath the earth, we believe
that He is universally present, and yet do not say that He is any of
those things in which He is (for He is not the Heaven, Who has marked
it out with His enfolding span, nor is He the earth, Who upholds the
circle of the earth, nor yet is He the water, Who encompasses the
liquid nature), so neither do we say that in passing through those
sufferings of the flesh of which we speak He was “subject to
passion,” but, as we say that He is the cause of all things that
are, that He holds the universe in His grasp, that He directs all that
is in motion and keeps upon a settled foundation all that is
stationary, by the unspeakable power of His own majesty, so we say that
He was born among us for the cure of the disease of sin, adapting the
exercise of His healing power in a manner corresponding to the
suffering, applying the healing in that way which He knew to be for the
good of that part of the creation which He knew to be in infirmity. And
as it was expedient that He should heal the sufferings by touch, we say
that He so healed it; yet is He not, because He is the Healer of our
infirmity, to be deemed on this account to have been Himself passible.
For even in the case of men, ordinary use does not allow us to affirm
such a thing. We do not say that one who touches a sick man to heal him
is himself partaker of the infirmity, but we say that he does give the
sick man the boon of a return to health, and does not partake of the
infirmity: for the suffering does not touch him, it is he who touches
the disease. Now if he who by his art works any good in men’s
bodies is not called dull or feeble, but is called a lover of men and a
benefactor and the like, why do they slander the dispensation to usward
as being mean and inglorious, and use it to maintain that the essence
of the Son is “divergent by way of inferiority,” on the
ground that the Nature of the Father is superior to sufferings, while
that of the Son is not pure from passion? Why, if the aim of the
dispensation of the Incarnation was not that the Son should be subject
to suffering, but that He should be manifested as a lover of men, while
the Father also is undoubtedly a lover of men, it follows that if one
will but regard the aim, the Son is in the same case with the Father.
But if it was not the Father Who wrought the destruction of death,
marvel not,—for all judgment also He hath committed unto the Son,
Himself judging no man Cf.
S. John v. 22; not doing all things
by the Son for the reason that He is unable either to save the lost or
judge the sinner, but because He does these things too by His own
Power, by which He works all things. Then they who were saved by the
Son were saved by the Power of the Father, and they who are judged by
Him undergo judgment by the Righteousness of God. For
“Christ,” as the Apostle says, “is the Righteousness
of God Rom. i. 17.,” which is revealed by the Gospel; and
whether you look at the world as a whole, or at the parts of the world
which make up that complete whole, all these are works of the Father,
in that they are works of His Power; and thus the word which says both
that the Father made all things, and that none of these things that are
came into being without the Son, speaks truly on both points; for the
operation of the Power bears relation to Him Whose Power It is. Thus,
since the Son is the Power of the Father, all the works of the Son are
works of the Father. That He entered upon the dispensation of the
Passion not by weakness of nature but by the power of His will, one
might bring countless passages of the Gospel to show; but these, as the
matter is clear, I will pretermit, that my discourse may not be
prolonged by dwelling on points that are admitted. If, then, that which
comes to pass is evil, we have to separate from that evil not the
Father only, but the Son also; but if the saving of them that were lost
is good, and if that which took place is not “passion That
is, “passion” in the sense defined above, as something with
evil tendency. If the γινόμενον
(i.e. the salvation of men) is evil, then
Father and Son alike must be “kept clear” from any
participation in it. If it is good, and if, therefore, the means (the
actual events) are not “passion” as not tending to evil,
while, considered in regard to their aim, they are φιλανθρωπία, then there is no reason why a share in their fulfilment
should be denied to the Father, Who, as well as the Son, is
φιλάνθρωπος, and Who by His own Power (that is, by Christ) wrought the
salvation of men.,” but love of men, why do you alienate
from our thanksgiving for our salvation the Father, Who by His own
Power, which is Christ, wrought for men their freedom from
death?