In the carrying out of this method of procedure I have
availed myself of all the translations which I could find, and where,
after comparing them with the original, I have thought them
substantially accurate, I have adopted them and reproduced them.
Where I have thought that the translation was misleading, I have
amended it from some other translation, and, I think, in no case have I
ventured a change of translation which rests upon my own judgment
alone. A very considerable portion, however, of the matter found
in this volume is now translated into English for the first time.
For some of this I am indebted to my friends, who have most kindly
given me every assistance in their power, but even here no translation
has been made from the Greek without careful reference being had to the
traditional understanding, as handed down in the Latin versions, and
wherever the Latin and Greek texts differ on material points the
difference has been noted. I have not thought it necessary nor
desirable to specify the source of each particular translation, but I
have provided for the use of the reader a list of all the translations
which I have used. I should also add that I have not considered
any one text sufficiently well established as to command any deference
being paid to it, and that I have usually followed (for my own
convenience rather than for any other reason) the text contained in
Labbe and Cossart’s Concilia. No doubt Hardouin and
Mansi are in some respects superior, but old prejudices are very
strong, and the reader will remember that these differing
Concilia gave rise to a hard-fought battle in the history of the
Gallican Church. I should add, however, that where more recent
students of the subject have detected errors of importance in
Labbe’s text, I have corrected them, usually noting the variety
of reading. With regard then to the text I entirely disclaim any
responsibility, and the more so as on such a matter my opinion would be
entirely valueless. And with regard to the translation my
responsibility goes no further than the certifying the reader that, to
all intents and purposes, the meaning of the original is presented to
him in the English language and without interpretation being introduced
under the specious guise of translation. Some portions are mere
literal translations, and some are
done into more idiomatic English, but all—so far as I am able to
judge—are fair renderings of the original, its ambiguities
being duly preserved. I have used as the foundation of the
translation of the canons of the first four synods and of the five
Provincial Synods that most convenient book, Index Canonum, by
the Rev. John Fulton, D.D., D.C.L., in which united to a good
translation is a Greek text, very well edited and clearly printed.