C214> MEMORIALS OF TWO SISTERS [1859-61
Evangelicalism, whereas Evangelicalism is as different from
the doctrines of John and Paul and the early fathers as the
two other modern developments of eighteenth century Uni-
tarianism and nineteenth century Romanism are, and far
morecramping and deadening to themind than Unitarianism
is at least. Of course I am here speaking of the ordinary
Unitarianism of Belsham, Priestley, &c., &c., and not of Mr.
Martineau's phase of Unitarianism, which is something very
different.
I think you hit the right nail on the head in wishing to
get at the " pith of the records of other faiths," that you
may
"
compare them with Christianity." That is really
the test of what is essentially Christian and not merely
Theistic. Miss Cobbe's letter would be the EXACT expres-
sion of what I thought some years ago, when my essential
spiritual beliefs and experiences were precisely the same as
now, and I too felt as if Christianity would be a sort of
limitation to my faith, at least to my communion with my
pious brethren who were not Christians, and how often have
I said to myself, like her, " I have come to the Father, that
is as certain to me as my own existence, and I certainly
have not come by Christ." Of course the answer of the
Evangelicals to this would be, "You have not come to
the Father
"
; the answer of Mr. Maurice and of Mr. Hutton,
" You have come and by Christ, unconsciously though not
consciously." I quite agree with Miss Cobbe now, that were
her view (and the Evangelical view) of what Christianity
is the true view, she would have " all to lose and nothing to
gain by becoming a Christian." For she would have to give
up the faith in a God who is by nature, and not only by
virtue of our choosing Him, our FATHER, and the Father of
the wholehuman race, heathen, Jewish, or Christian, and who
speaks by His Spirit to all in various degrees, for the faith
in a father who has confined the revelation of his love to
certain races and ages, and whose love to us can be averted
by our refusing to believe in his son. But I do not so read
St. Paul and St. John. Theism does seem to me sufficient
for the individual life of piety. Theism as much as