51.5031 But suppose that the deity was present in that very stone, as you demand should
be believed: and what mortal is there, although he may be credulous and very ready to listen
to any fictions you please, who would consider that she either was a goddess at that time,
or should be now so spoken of and named, who at one time desires these things, at another
requires those, abandons and despises her worshippers, leaves the humbler provinces, and
allies herself with more powerful and richer peoples, truly5032 loves warfare, and wishes to
be in the midst of battles, slaughter, death, and blood? If it is characteristic of the gods—if
only they are true gods, and those who it is fitting should be named according to the
meaning of this word and the power of divinity—to do5033 nothing wickedly, nothing un-
justly, to show5034 themselves equally gracious to all men without any partiality, would any
man believe that she was of divine origin, or showed5035 kindness worthy of the gods, who,
mixing herself up with the dissensions of men, destroyed the power of some, gave and
showed favour to others, bereft some of their liberty, raised others to the height of
power,—who, that one state might be pre-eminent, having been born to be the bane of the
human race, subjugated the guiltless world?
5031 48 in Orelli.
5032 All edd., except Hild. and Oehler, begin a new sentence here, and change the construction, seemingly
following the mistake of the 1st ed.
5033 “To do…to show;” so the edd., dropping -nt from the ms. facere-nt…præbere-nt.
5034 “To do…to show;” so the edd., dropping -nt from the ms. facere-nt…præbere-nt.
5035 Lit, “showed.” Ursinus and Heraldus supposed that some paragraphs are now wanting which were ori-
ginally found here. It should be noticed that in the ms. the usual subscription is found denoting the end of a
book. “The seventh book of Arnovius (sic) ends, the eighth (i.e., Octavius of Minucius Felix) begins,” so that the
present arrangement is not due to the binder, nor clearly to the copyist who wrote these words. Nothing can be
more certain than that we do not have these chapters as Arnobius intended to leave them; but there is not the
slightest reason to suppose that he actually left them otherwise than they have come down to us. Remembering
this, we may well suppose that we have only the first draught of them. If so, the difficulties vanish, for nothing
would be more natural than that, when Arnobius was drawing near the close of his work, the ideas of the con-
clusion in which the discussion was to be fairly summed up should force themselves upon his attention, and
that he should therefore turn aside at once to give them expression roughly, without seeking completeness and
elaboration, and should then hastily resume his argument, of course with the intention of afterwards revising
and re-arranging the whole. We may infer that the re-arrangement was never effected, as there are sufficient
proofs that the revision was never accomplished, whatever may have been the reason.
Chapter LI.
1321
Chapter LI.