to wait longer, or use any further means for light, or to take any further or other course for
a remedy from our calamities. At last a vow was passed in these words,—‘That a council
should be called to give us their last advice, for a remedy from the calamities arising from
the present unsettled, broken state of the church, by reason of the controversy here subsisting,
concerning the qualifications for full communion in the church: and if upon the whole of
what they see and find in our circumstances, they judge it best that pastor and people be
immediately separated, that they proceed to dissolve the relation between them.’ Accordingly
a council was agreed upon, to meet here on this business, on June 19th. I nominated two
out of this county; of which Mr. Foxcroft’s church in Boston was one. But others were
nominated provisionally, in case these should fall. Those that came, were Mr. Hall’s church
of Sutton, and Mr. Hobby’s church in Reading. One of the churches that I nominated
within the county, refused to send a delegate, viz. Mr. Billing’s church of Cold Spring.
However, Mr. Billing himself (though with some difficulty) was admitted into the council.
The people, in managing this affair on their side, have made chief use of a young gentleman
of liberal education and notable abilities, and a fluent speaker, of about seven or eight and
twenty years of age, my grandfather Stoddard’s grandson, being my mother’s sister’s son; a
man of lax principles in religion, falling in, in some essential things, with Arminians, and
is very open and bold in it. He was improved as one of the agents for the church, and was
their chief spokesman before the council. He very strenuously urged before the council the
necessity of an immediate separation; and I knowing the church, the most of them, to be
inflexibly bent on this event, informed the council that I should not enter into the dispute,
but should refer the matter wholly to the council’s judgment; I signified, that I had no desire
to leave my people, on any other consideration, any other than their aversion to my being
their minister any longer; but, they continuing so averse, had no inclination or desire that
they should be compelled, but yet should refer myself to their advice. When the church was
convened, in order to the council’s knowing their minds with respect to my continuance,
about twenty-three appeared for it, others staid away, choosing not to act either way; but
the generality of the church, which consists of about 230 male members, voted for my dis-
mission. My dismission was carried in the council by a majority of one voice. The ministers
were equally divided, but of the delegates one more was for it than against it, and it so
happened that all those of the council, who came from the churches of the people’s choosing,
voted for my dismission; but all those who came from the churches that I chose, were against
it, and there happening to be one fewer of these than of the other, by the church of Cold
Spring not sending a delegate, (which was through that people’s prejudice against my
opinion,) the vote was carried that way by the voice of one delegate. However, on the 22d
of the last month, the relation between me and this people was dissolved. I suppose that the
Result of the Council, and the Protestation of some of the members, are printed in Boston
by this time. I shall endeavour to procure one of the printed accounts, to be sent with this
246
CHAPTER XVII. Account of difficulties at Northampton continued