The charges against all the exiles were carefully
examined and dismissed. This was also the case with the complaints
against the orthodoxy of Marcellus, who was allowed to evade the very
point which gave most offence (p. 125). Probably the ocular evidence
(p. 124) of the violence which many present had suffered, indisposed
the fathers to believe any accusations from such a quarter. The synod
next proceeded to legislate. Their canons were twenty in number, the
most important being canons 3–5, which permit a deposed bishop to
demand the reference of his case to ‘Julius bishop of
Rome,’ ‘honouring the memory of Peter the Apostle;’
the deposition to be suspended pending such reference; the Roman
bishop, if the appeal seem reasonable, to request the rehearing of the
case in its own province, and if at the request of the accused he sends
a presbyter to represent him, such presbyter to rank as though he were
his principal in person. The whole scheme appears to be novel and to
have been suggested by the history of the case of the exiles. The
canons are very important in their subsequent history, but need not be
discussed here. (Elaborate discussions in Hefele, pp. 112–129;
see also D.C.A. pp. 127 sq., 1658, 1671, Greenwood, Cath.
Petr. i. 204–208, D.C.B. iii. 662 a, and especially
529–531.) The only legislation, however, to which Athanasius
alludes is that establishing a period of 50 years during which Rome and
Alexandria should agree as to the period for Easter (Fest. Ind.
xv., infr. p. 544, also Hefele pp. 157 sqq.). The
arrangement averted a dispute in 346, but differences occurred in spite
of it in 349, 350, 360, and 368.