16. Origen (in Evang. Johan. tom. vi. 2, vol. iv. p. 102) blames Heracleon for terminating the testimony of John at the end of Joh 1:17, and makes it continue to the end of Joh 1:18. But it can hardly be that his testimony extends beyond John 1:15, for ἡμεῖςπάντες would bear no very definite meaning, and the assertions in John 1:17 would be alien from the character of the Baptist, belonging as they do to the more mature development of Christian doctrines. I cannot doubt that this and the following verses belong to the Evangelist, and are a carrying onwards of his declarations concerning the divine Word.
John 1:15 is not parenthetical, but confirmatory of Joh 1:14, and this verse grounds itself on the fact of Joh 1:14, corroborated by the testimony of Joh 1:15,—that He dwelt among us, and that we saw His glory, full of grace and truth.
τὸπλήρωμα is that of which He was ð ë Þ ñ ç ò, John 1:14, and is not connected with the Gnostic pleroma at all. See reff.
ἡμεῖςπάντες ] All who believe on Him: see John 1:12.
ἐλάβομεν, ê á ß ] received, and that … ‘our relation to Him has been that of recipients out of His fulness, and the thing received has been’.…So Herod. i. 102, ἔχωνδύοταῦταἔθνεα, καὶἀμφότεραἰσχυρά.
χάρινἀντὶχάριτος ] The ancient interpretation, τὴνκαινὴνδιαθήκηνἀντὶτῆςπαλαιᾶς (Euthym[19]), is certainly wrong, for the ἐλάβομεν is spoken entirely of the times of the Incarnate Word: and besides, ὁνόμος and ÷ Ü ñ é ò are distinctly opposed to one another in the next verse.
[19] Euthymius Zigabenus, 1116
The prep. ἀντί is properly used of any thing which supersedes another, or occupies its place. This is in fact its ordinary usage when exchange is spoken of: the possession of the thing gotten succeeds to, supersedes, the possession of the thing given in exchange, and I possess τοῦτοἀντὶἐκείνου. Thus also we have received χάρινἀντὶχάριτος continual accessions of grace; new grace coining upon and superseding the former. Thus in Theognis, Sentt. 343 ff. (Lücke), ô å è í á ß ç í ä ʼ εἰμήτικακῶνἄμπαυμαμεριμνέων | εὑροίμην, ä ï ß ç ò ä ʼ ἀντ ʼ ἀνιῶνἀνίας. And Chrysostom, de Sacerdotio, 6. 13, vol. i. p. 435, σὺδέμεἐκπέμπεις, ἑτέρανἀνθ ʼ ἑτέραςφροντίδαἐνθείς. Also Philo, i. 254, speaking of this very word ÷ Ü ñ é ò:— τὰςπρώταςἀεὶχάριτας … ἐπισχὼνκαὶταμιευσάμενοςεἰσαῦθιςἑτέραςἀντὶἐκείνωνκαὶτρίταςἀντὶδευτέρων, καὶἀεὶνέαςἀντὶπαλαιοτέρων, τότεμὲνδιαφορούσας, ô ü ô å ä ʼ αὖκαὶτὰςαὐτὰςἐπιδίδωσι.