Then he adds to this something
by which his profanity is yet more completely stripped of all disguise,
so that its absurdity is obvious even to a child. For he
says,—“It would be a long task to detail all the modes of
generation of intelligible objects, or the essences which do not all
possess the nature of the Existent in common, but display variations
according to the operations of Him Who constructed them.” Without
any words of ours, the blasphemy against the Son which is here
contained is glaring and conspicuous, when he acknowledges that that
which is predicated of every mode of generation and essence in nowise
differs from the description of the Divine subsistence ὑποστασέως of the Only-begotten. But it seems to me
best to pass over the intermediate passages in which he seeks to
maintain his profanity, and to hasten to the head and front of the
accusation which we have to bring against his doctrines. For he will be
found to exhibit the sacrament of regeneration as an idle thing, the
mystic oblation as profitless, and the participation in them as of no
advantage to those who are partakers therein. For after those
high-wrought æons The
word seems to be used, as “octads” in Book IX. seems to be
used, of sections of Eunomius’ production. in which, by way of
disparagement of our doctrine, he names as its supporters a Valentinus,
a Cerinthus, a Basilides, a Montanus, and a Marcion, and after laying
it down that those who affirm that the Divine nature is unknowable, and
the mode of His generation unknowable, have no right or title whatever
to the name of Christians, and after reckoning us among those whom he
thus disparages, he proceeds to develop his own view in these
terms:—“But we, in agreement with holy and blessed men;
affirm that the mystery of godliness does not consist in venerable
names, nor in the distinctive character of customs and sacramental
tokens, but in exactness of doctrine.” That when he wrote this,
he did so not under the guidance of evangelists, apostles, or any of
the authors of the Old Testament, is plain to every one who has any
acquaintance with the sacred and Divine Scripture. We should naturally
be led to suppose that by “holy and blessed men” he meant
Manichæus, Nicolaus, Colluthus, Aetius, Arius, and the rest of the
same band, with whom he is in strict accord in laying down this
principle, that neither the confession of sacred names, nor the customs
of the Church, nor her sacramental tokens, are a ratification of
godliness. But we, having learnt from the holy voice of Christ that
“except a man be born again of water and of the Spirit he shall
not enter into the kingdom of God Cf.
S. John iii. 3 and 6.” and
that “He that eateth My flesh and drinketh My blood, shall live
for ever Cf.
S. John vi. 51 and
54.,” are persuaded that the mystery
of godliness is ratified by the confession of the Divine
Names—the Names of the Father, the Son, and the Holy Ghost, and
that our salvation is confirmed by participation in the sacramental
customs and tokens. But doctrines have often been carefully
investigated by those who have had no part or lot in that mystery, and
one may hear many such putting forward the faith we hold as a subject
for themselves in the rivalry of debate, and some of them often even
succeeding in hitting the truth, and for all that none the less
estranged from the faith. Since, then, he despises the revered Names,
by which the power of the more Divine birth distributes grace to them
who come for it in faith, and slights the fellowship of the sacramental
customs and tokens from which the Christian profession draws its
vigour, let us, with a slight variation, utter to those who listen to
his deceit the word of the prophet:—“How long will ye be
slow of heart? Why do ye love destruction and seek after leasing Cf. Ps. iv. 2 (LXX.). The alteration made is the substitution of
ἀπώλειαν for ματαιότητα?” How is it that ye do not see the
persecutor of the faith inviting those who consent unto him to violate
their Christian profession? For if the confession of the revered and
precious Names of the Holy Trinity is useless, and the customs of the
Church unprofitable, and if among these customs is the sign of the
cross ῾Η σφραγίς. The term is used elsewhere by Gregory in this sense, in
the Life of S. Gregory Thaumaturgus, and in the Life of S.
Macrina., prayer, baptism, confession of sins, a
ready zeal to keep the commandment, right ordering of character,
sobriety of life, regard to justice, the effort not to be excited by
passion, or enslaved by pleasure, or to fall short in moral
excellence,—if he says that none of such habits as these is
cultivated to any good purpose, and that the sacramental tokens do not,
as we have believed, secure spiritual blessings, and avert from
believers the assaults directed against them by the wiles of the evil
one, what else does he do but openly proclaim aloud to men that he
deems the mystery which Christians cherish a fable, laughs at the
majesty of the Divine Names, considers the customs of the Church a
jest, and all sacramental operations idle prattle and folly? What
beyond this do they who remain attached to paganism bring forward in
disparagement of our creed? Do not they too make the majesty of the
sacred Names, in which the faith is ratified, an occasion of laughter?
Do not they deride the sacramental tokens and the customs which are
observed by the initiated? And of whom is it so much a distinguishing
peculiarity as of the pagans, to think that piety should consist in
doctrines only? since they also say that according to their view, there
is something more persuasive than the Gospel which we preach,
and some of
them hold that there is some one great God preeminent above the rest,
and acknowledge some subject powers, differing among themselves in the
way of superiority or inferiority, in some regular order and sequence,
but all alike subject to the Supreme. This, then, is what the teachers
of the new idolatry preach, and they who follow them have no dread of
the condemnation that abideth on transgressors, as though they did not
understand that actually to do some improper thing is far more grievous
than to err in word alone. They, then, who in act deny the faith, and
slight the confession of the sacred Names, and judge the sanctification
effected by the sacramental tokens to be worthless, and have been
persuaded to have regard to cunningly devised fables, and to fancy that
their salvation consists in quibbles about the generate and the
ungenerate,—what else are they than transgressors of the
doctrines of salvation?