Accordingly when it reached my ears on reliable
testimony (and I already felt a brother’s affectionate anxiety
about your acts, beloved) that in what is one of the chief sacraments
of the Church you depart from the practice of the Apostles’
constitution From this letter it
might be gathered that it was a universal practice of the early Church
based on the precepts of the apostles, to restrict Baptism to the
feasts of Easter and Whitsuntide, and exclude Epiphany. Whereas
as a matter of fact the restriction was almost exclusively Roman; all
the Eastern Churches and a good many of the Western recognizing the
Epiphany as a suitable occasion for the rite. Leo is too fond of
claiming Apostolic authority for his dictates, and none such exists
here, as far as we know. by administering
the sacrament of baptism to greater numbers on the feast of the
Epiphany than at Easter-tide, I was surprised that you or your
predecessors could have introduced so unreasonable an innovation as to
confound the mysteries of the two festivals and believe there was no
difference between the day on which Christ was worshipped by the wise
men and that on which He rose again from the dead. You could
never have fallen into this fault, if you had taken the whole of your
observances from the source whence you derive your consecration to the
episcopate; and if the see of the blessed Apostle Peter, which is the
mother of your priestly dignity, were the recognized teacher of
church-method. We could indeed have endured your departure from
its rules with less equanimity, if you had received any previous rebuke
by way of warning from us. But now as we do not despair of
correcting you, we must show gentleness. And although an excuse
which affects ignorance is scarce tolerable in priests, yet we prefer
to moderate our needful rebuke and to instruct you plainly in the true
method of the Church.