To offset these faults we must take account, on the
other hand, of the persistent and successful attempt of our historian
at impartiality. Of all the Christian writers of his day he is the
fairest towards those who differed from the creed of his church. No one
else has done justice to Julian,
III. 1, 12, 14, 21, 23.
or to the various heretical sects of the day, as Socrates has. To avoid
even the appearance of partiality, he makes a rule for himself not to
speak in terms of praise of any living person;
VI. Int.
and it must be said that he faithfully observes this rule, making but
one exception in favor of the emperor Theodosius the Younger.
VII. 22.
Of this prince he gives a eulogistic picture, altogether different from
the representations universally found in the other historians of the
age.
Cf. Sozomen, IX. 1, and Gibbon, IV. 163.
His independence of judgment is more signally manifested in his
estimates of ecclesiastics, especially the more prominent ones,
Cf. attitude towards Chrysostom and Cyril of
Alexandria, above alluded to; also his censure of pride and contention
among members of the clergy. See V. Int. 15, 23; VI. 6; VII. 11,
29.
bordering at times on unjust severity. ‘In short,’ says
Harnack, summing up his estimate of Socrates, ‘the rule to be
applied to Socrates is that his learning and knowledge can be trusted
only a little, but his good will and straightforwardness a great deal.
Considering the circumstances under which he wrote and the miseries of
the times, it can only be matter for congratulation that such a man
should have been our informant and that his work has been preserved to
us.’
In Encycl. Britan.